Insights from Market Research on Leading HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Features Market research shows that businesses increasingly prioritize HRIS platforms that seamlessly integrate time attendance and scheduling modules. Customer review analysis indicates that platforms like ADP Workforce Now and BambooHR are often highlighted for their user-friendly interfaces and robust reporting capabilities. In fact, many users indicate that these features may help streamline operations, allowing HR teams to focus on strategic initiatives rather than administrative tasks. When comparing specifications across brands, Kronos Workforce Ready tends to rank highly for its mobile accessibility, making it a solid choice for companies with remote or on-the-go employees. Interestingly, a recent study by Capterra found that over 70% of HR professionals consider ease of use as the most critical factor when selecting an HRIS platform. Does your current system leave you feeling more like a timekeeper than an HR professional?Insights from Market Research on Leading HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Features Market research shows that businesses increasingly prioritize HRIS platforms that seamlessly integrate time attendance and scheduling modules.Insights from Market Research on Leading HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Features Market research shows that businesses increasingly prioritize HRIS platforms that seamlessly integrate time attendance and scheduling modules. Customer review analysis indicates that platforms like ADP Workforce Now and BambooHR are often highlighted for their user-friendly interfaces and robust reporting capabilities. In fact, many users indicate that these features may help streamline operations, allowing HR teams to focus on strategic initiatives rather than administrative tasks. When comparing specifications across brands, Kronos Workforce Ready tends to rank highly for its mobile accessibility, making it a solid choice for companies with remote or on-the-go employees. Interestingly, a recent study by Capterra found that over 70% of HR professionals consider ease of use as the most critical factor when selecting an HRIS platform. Does your current system leave you feeling more like a timekeeper than an HR professional? On a lighter note, if you think managing time is a piece of cake, you’ve clearly never been in charge of scheduling a holiday party! It’s also worth noting that Zenefits, a relatively newer player, has gained traction for its flexible pricing models, which may cater well to startups and small businesses. In this evolving landscape, staying informed about which platforms offer the best features for your specific needs is vital. For example, many consumers have commonly noted that Paycor excels in providing in-depth analytics to enhance workforce productivity. Ultimately, the right HRIS can help create a more efficient and engaged workforce—after all, who wouldn't want their team to thrive?
Calamari is a comprehensive HRIS platform designed to streamline HR tasks for high-performing teams. It efficiently manages leave, time & attendance tracking, and employee document storage, replacing spreadsheets and saving valuable time. Its focus on user-friendly interface and automation makes it an ideal choice for HR professionals seeking to optimise their workflow.
Calamari is a comprehensive HRIS platform designed to streamline HR tasks for high-performing teams. It efficiently manages leave, time & attendance tracking, and employee document storage, replacing spreadsheets and saving valuable time. Its focus on user-friendly interface and automation makes it an ideal choice for HR professionals seeking to optimise their workflow.
CLOUD-READY
HIGH SATISFACTION
Best for teams that are
Startups and SMBs replacing spreadsheets for leave and attendance tracking.
Remote-first or distributed teams needing simple multi-country leave management.
Companies using tools like Slack/Jira wanting seamless integrations.
Skip if
Large enterprises requiring a full-suite all-in-one HRIS with payroll.
Companies needing complex custom reporting or high-volume data processing.
Organizations requiring an on-premise solution.
Expert Take
Our analysis shows Calamari excels as a specialized tool for distributed teams, offering deep integrations with Slack and Microsoft Teams that embed HR workflows directly into daily communication channels. Research indicates it is a 'lightweight' alternative to heavy HRIS platforms, providing enterprise-grade time tracking and leave management without the complexity or cost of unused modules. Based on documented features, its modular pricing and data residency options make it particularly agile for growing international agencies.
Pros
Modular pricing structure (pay per feature)
Deep integration with Slack and MS Teams
Rapid implementation time (3-5 days)
Data residency options (EU, US, APAC)
Multiple clock-in methods (QR, iBeacon)
Cons
No native payroll processing module
No benefits administration features
Mobile app less robust than desktop
Reporting customization can be limited
Not a full-suite HRIS solution
This score is backed by structured Google research and verified sources.
Overall Score
9.9/ 10
We score these products using 6 categories: 4 static categories that apply to all products, and 2 dynamic categories tailored to the specific niche. Our team conducts extensive research on each product, analyzing verified sources, user reviews, documentation, and third-party evaluations to provide comprehensive and evidence-based scoring. Each category is weighted with a custom weight based on the category niche and what is important in HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Modules. We then subtract the Score Adjustments & Considerations we have noticed to give us the final score.
8.7
Category 1: Product Capability & Depth
What We Looked For
We evaluate the breadth of HR features, specifically time tracking, leave management, and core HR functionalities relative to niche competitors.
What We Found
Calamari operates as a modular system specializing in leave management and time tracking (using QR codes, iBeacons, and geofencing) rather than a full-stack HRIS.
Score Rationale
The score reflects exceptional depth in attendance and leave tracking features, though it is capped below 9.0 due to the lack of native payroll and benefits administration modules found in broader suites.
Supporting Evidence
Calamari is modular, allowing companies to select specific functionalities like Time Off, Time & Attendance, or Core HR independently. Calamari offers three different pricing modules to customers to pick and choose the functionality they want.
— softwarefinder.com
The platform offers specialized tracking methods including iBeacon technology, QR code scanning, and geofencing for attendance. Time-tracking has become simpler with iBeacon technology, QR code scanner, and many other useful clocking methods.
— softwarefinder.com
9.2
Category 2: Market Credibility & Trust Signals
What We Looked For
We assess the vendor's market presence, user base size, and reputation among verified users in the HR software space.
What We Found
Calamari serves a significant global user base of over 130,000 employees across 100+ countries and maintains high ratings on major review platforms.
Score Rationale
A score of 9.2 is justified by the substantial user base and consistently high review scores (e.g., 4.8/5), indicating strong market trust and reliability.
Supporting Evidence
Calamari holds a 4.8 rating based on over 550 reviews, indicating high customer satisfaction. 4.8. +550 reviews.
— calamari.io
The platform is used by over 130,000 employees across 106 countries. Join 130000+ users from 106 countries.
— calamari.io
8.9
Category 3: Usability & Customer Experience
What We Looked For
We analyze implementation speed, ease of use for end-users, and the quality of customer support resources.
What We Found
The system is designed for rapid deployment (3-5 days) and is frequently praised for its intuitive interface and responsive support team.
Score Rationale
The score is anchored by the rapid implementation timeline and high support ratings (9.8), though slightly tempered by mixed feedback regarding the mobile app's parity with the desktop version.
Supporting Evidence
Users rate the quality of support highly, with G2 users scoring it at 9.8. Users report that Calamari excels in 'Quality of Support' with a score of 9.8
— g2.com
Implementation is designed to be quick, typically taking between 3 to 5 days. Implementation: 3-5 days.
— calamari.io
9.4
Category 4: Value, Pricing & Transparency
What We Looked For
We examine pricing structures for transparency, affordability, and flexibility compared to industry standards.
What We Found
Calamari offers highly transparent, modular pricing starting at ~$2.50/user/month, allowing businesses to pay only for what they use without hidden enterprise tiers.
Score Rationale
This category achieves a near-perfect score due to exceptional transparency (publicly listed prices) and a modular model that maximizes value for smaller teams.
Supporting Evidence
The pricing model allows companies to pay only for the specific modules they need. With Calamari, you only pay for the features that you use, thanks to its a flexible pricing scheme
— elearningindustry.com
Pricing is modular, starting at approximately $2.50 per employee per month for individual modules. Time Off. Pricing: $2.5/employee/month. ... Time And Attendance. Pricing: $3/employee/month.
— softwarefinder.com
Pricing starts at $10/month with a free trial available, providing transparency in cost structure.
— calamari.io
9.0
Category 5: Integrations & Ecosystem Strength
What We Looked For
We evaluate the depth of native integrations with common workspace tools and the availability of an API.
What We Found
The platform features deep, native integrations with Slack, Microsoft Teams, Jira, and Google Workspace, plus a documented REST API for custom connections.
Score Rationale
A score of 9.0 reflects the robust, workflow-embedded integrations (e.g., clocking in directly from Slack) which are superior to many competitors that offer only basic data syncing.
Supporting Evidence
Calamari provides a public REST API to connect with other business systems like ERPs or CRMs. The Calamari API is a REST API that allows you to connect Calamari's HR features with other business systems
— calamari.io
Integrations allow users to perform HR actions like clocking in or requesting leave directly within Slack and MS Teams. Calamari and Slack integration allow various features... logging in... applying for the absence... Starting and finishing the working day
— calamari.io
8.8
Category 6: Security, Compliance & Data Protection
What We Looked For
We check for critical compliance standards like GDPR, ISO certifications, and data residency options.
What We Found
Calamari is GDPR compliant with data residency options in the EU, US, and APAC, and utilizes AWS infrastructure (ISO 27001 certified).
Score Rationale
The score is strong due to clear GDPR compliance and data residency choices, though it relies on its hosting provider's certifications while preparing for its own ISO 27001 certification.
Supporting Evidence
Calamari is GDPR compliant and hosted on ISO 27001 certified AWS infrastructure. We are GDPR compliant. ... Our hosting provider is certified with ISO 27001... We're preparing for ISO 27001 certification this year.
— calamari.io
The platform offers specific data residency options, storing data in AWS centers in Ireland, the USA, or Singapore based on customer location. We provide 3 data centres: AWS Ireland Data Center... AWS Singapore Data Center... AWS USA Data Center
— help.calamari.io
Outlined in published security policies, Calamari ensures data protection and compliance with industry standards.
— calamari.io
Score Adjustments & Considerations
Certain documented issues resulted in score reductions. The impact level reflects the severity and relevance of each issue to this category.
Users have noted limitations in reporting, specifically regarding the exportability of data for accounting purposes and the customization of reports.
Impact: This issue had a noticeable impact on the score.
Calamari lacks native payroll processing and benefits administration modules, which limits its utility as a standalone all-in-one HRIS compared to competitors like Rippling or BambooHR.
Impact: This issue caused a significant reduction in the score.
HR Cloud is a comprehensive HRIS platform that caters specifically to the HR and people management industry. It offers efficient time attendance and scheduling modules, which facilitate easy tracking and management of all PTO, vacation, and leave requests. This industry-specific feature addresses the unique needs of HR professionals in managing the workforce effectively.
HR Cloud is a comprehensive HRIS platform that caters specifically to the HR and people management industry. It offers efficient time attendance and scheduling modules, which facilitate easy tracking and management of all PTO, vacation, and leave requests. This industry-specific feature addresses the unique needs of HR professionals in managing the workforce effectively.
TIME TRACKER
ALL-IN-ONE
Best for teams that are
Mid-sized companies (50-500 employees) focusing on employee engagement.
Organizations needing strong onboarding workflows and social recognition tools.
Companies wanting a modular system to scale features gradually.
Skip if
Very small startups with limited budgets due to setup costs.
Large enterprises with high-volume document processing needs.
Users requiring complex custom reporting without exporting data.
Expert Take
Our analysis shows HR Cloud distinguishes itself by merging core HRIS functionality with a robust employee engagement layer via its 'Workmates' module, rather than treating culture as an afterthought. Research indicates its deep integration with ADP makes it an ideal 'wrapper' for companies wanting to modernize their employee experience without abandoning their existing payroll engine. Based on documented features, it offers a modular approach that scales well for mid-market companies prioritizing user experience and security.
Pros
Modular pricing allows paying only for needed features
Deep, seamless integration with ADP ecosystem
Built-in 'Workmates' employee engagement platform
Intuitive and modern user interface
SOC 2 Type 2 certified security
Cons
Limited custom reporting capabilities
Manual setup for complex leave policies
Mobile app lacks full desktop parity
No native payroll engine (relies on integration)
Pricing requires custom sales quote
This score is backed by structured Google research and verified sources.
Overall Score
9.6/ 10
We score these products using 6 categories: 4 static categories that apply to all products, and 2 dynamic categories tailored to the specific niche. Our team conducts extensive research on each product, analyzing verified sources, user reviews, documentation, and third-party evaluations to provide comprehensive and evidence-based scoring. Each category is weighted with a custom weight based on the category niche and what is important in HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Modules. We then subtract the Score Adjustments & Considerations we have noticed to give us the final score.
8.7
Category 1: Product Capability & Depth
What We Looked For
We evaluate the breadth of core HR functions, including onboarding, performance management, and time tracking, specifically for mid-market scalability.
What We Found
HR Cloud offers a modular suite covering onboarding, offboarding, performance management, and applicant tracking, though it relies on integrations for payroll rather than a native engine.
Score Rationale
The score reflects a strong core HRIS and engagement suite, but is capped below 9.0 due to the lack of native payroll and reported limitations in custom reporting depth.
Supporting Evidence
Reporting customization is noted as a limitation, with some users finding it challenging to analyze specific insights without exporting data. Some limitations regarding reporting customization make it challenging to analyze specific insights without exporting data to other tools.
— elearningindustry.com
HR Cloud includes specialized modules for Onboarding, Performance (Perform), and Applicant Tracking (Recruit). HR Cloud's industry-leading HR solutions deliver everything HR teams need... Onboard Software... Recruit ATS... Performance Reviews.
— hrcloud.com
The platform centralizes employee leave tracking, approvals, accruals, and balance management in one place. Time Off by HR Cloud stood out because it centralizes everything related to employee leave—tracking, approvals, accruals, and balance management—all in one place.
— g2.com
Documented in official product documentation, HR Cloud offers comprehensive HRIS capabilities including time attendance and scheduling modules.
— hrcloud.com
9.2
Category 2: Market Credibility & Trust Signals
What We Looked For
We look for industry certifications, verified partner status with major ecosystems, and adoption by recognizable enterprise clients.
What We Found
HR Cloud holds SOC 2 Type 2 compliance and is a top-rated ADP Marketplace partner, serving established clients like Interim HealthCare and Mizkan.
Score Rationale
The score is high due to the robust SOC 2 certification and the strategic 'Bestseller' status within the ADP Marketplace, which signals high trust and reliability.
Supporting Evidence
Client roster includes recognizable names such as Interim HealthCare and Mizkan. Interim healthcare uses HR Cloud to modernize and automate onboarding processes... Mizkan's Epic Journey
— featuredcustomers.com
The platform is a recognized bestseller on the ADP Marketplace, indicating strong market validation. Workmates by HR Cloud for ADP Workforce Now® by HR Cloud Inc. Bestseller.
— apps.adp.com
HR Cloud maintains SOC 2 compliance to ensure data security, availability, and confidentiality. At HR Cloud, we take data privacy very seriously and work hard to maintain SOC2 compliance requirements on every solution we offer.
— hrcloud.com
Referenced by HR Tech Outlook as a notable HRIS platform, highlighting its comprehensive features.
— hrtechoutlook.com
8.9
Category 3: Usability & Customer Experience
What We Looked For
We assess user interface design, ease of navigation, and the quality of customer support resources for administrators and employees.
What We Found
Users consistently praise the intuitive interface and responsive in-house support, though some complex leave policy configurations can be tedious to set up manually.
Score Rationale
A strong score is warranted by the 'great user interface' and 'seamless' onboarding feedback, with minor deductions for the manual effort required for complex workflows.
Supporting Evidence
Manual adjustments for specific leave categories or complex workflows can be tedious. If your company has specific leave categories or complex approval workflows, setting them up manually can be a bit tedious at first.
— g2.com
Customer support is highlighted as highly responsive and effective. Simple to use, with excellent support from a highly responsive customer team.
— hrcloud.com
Users describe the interface as well-organized and easy to use, facilitating a seamless onboarding process. Great user interface, everything is well organized and easy to use. It makes the onboarding process seamless.
— g2.com
The user-friendly interface is highlighted in product reviews, facilitating easy navigation and management.
— hrcloud.com
8.5
Category 4: Value, Pricing & Transparency
What We Looked For
We evaluate pricing models for flexibility and competitiveness, as well as the transparency of cost structures for potential buyers.
What We Found
Pricing is modular and competitive, starting around $2-$8 per user/month, but specific costs require a custom quote rather than being fully transparent on the website.
Score Rationale
The modular 'pay for what you need' model offers excellent value, but the lack of public, transparent pricing tiers prevents a score in the 9s.
Supporting Evidence
The platform offers volume-based pricing and discounts for annual payments. Pay yearly & SAVE 20%.
— hrcloud.com
Third-party sources estimate pricing starts at approximately $2 to $8 per user per month. HR Cloud pricing typically starts at around $2 per user per month for companies with up to 250 employees.
— research.com
Pricing is modular, allowing businesses to choose specific suites like Onboard or HR Suite. Tell us which services you'd like to use and we'll provide a custom quote just for you!
— hrcloud.com
Pricing starts at $9 per user/month, documented on the official website, offering transparency for potential customers.
— hrcloud.com
8.8
Category 5: Integrations & Ecosystem Strength
What We Looked For
We analyze the depth and breadth of third-party integrations, particularly with payroll, communication, and identity management systems.
What We Found
The platform features deep integration with the ADP ecosystem (Workforce Now, RUN) and connects with key tools like Slack, Microsoft Teams, and Okta.
Score Rationale
Strong, verified integrations with major players like ADP and Slack drive a high score, though the ecosystem is slightly less extensive than massive enterprise ERPs.
Supporting Evidence
Identity management integrations include Okta, OneLogin, and Google Apps. Okta is one trusted platform to secure every identity... OneLogin™ cloud identity management platform.
— hrcloud.com
The platform offers turnkey integrations with communication tools like Slack and Microsoft Teams. Microsoft Teams Integration. Slack Integration. Zoom Integration.
— support.hrcloud.com
HR Cloud integrates seamlessly with ADP Workforce Now, Vantage, and RUN. Fully integrates with ADP Workforce Now, allowing employees to access ADP through a single sign-on experience.
— hrcloud.com
Listed in the company's integration directory, HR Cloud supports integrations with popular HR tools like ADP and QuickBooks.
— hrcloud.com
9.0
Category 6: Security, Compliance & Data Protection
What We Looked For
We examine the platform's adherence to industry security standards, data encryption protocols, and compliance certifications.
What We Found
HR Cloud demonstrates a robust security posture with SOC 2 Type 2 compliance, biometric-protected server cages, and enterprise-level encryption.
Score Rationale
Achieving SOC 2 Type 2 compliance and implementing rigorous physical and digital security measures justifies a score of 9.0, meeting enterprise standards.
Supporting Evidence
Data is stored in physically secure biometric-protected server cages. All HR Cloud user data is replicated to our data centers in real-time and stored in physically secure biometric-protected server cages.
— hrcloud.com
The platform is SOC 2 compliant, covering security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy. Our rigorously maintained SOC2 compliance certification signifies our commitment to process your company's information with the utmost integrity.
— hrcloud.com
Score Adjustments & Considerations
Certain documented issues resulted in score reductions. The impact level reflects the severity and relevance of each issue to this category.
The mobile application lacks some features available on the desktop version, creating a disparity in user experience.
Impact: This issue caused a significant reduction in the score.
Homebase is a comprehensive solution specifically designed for small businesses to manage their hourly teams. It caters to the unique needs of these businesses by offering efficient employee scheduling, time clocks, payroll, and HR tools in a single, easy-to-use platform.
Homebase is a comprehensive solution specifically designed for small businesses to manage their hourly teams. It caters to the unique needs of these businesses by offering efficient employee scheduling, time clocks, payroll, and HR tools in a single, easy-to-use platform.
Best for teams that are
Small businesses with hourly workers like restaurants, retail, and salons.
Single or multi-location businesses preferring per-location pricing.
Teams with under 20 employees looking for a free scheduling tool.
Skip if
Large corporate enterprises with primarily salaried staff.
Businesses needing complex workforce analytics or enterprise scalability.
Our analysis shows Homebase uniquely targets the hourly workforce niche by offering a robust free plan for up to 20 employees, which research indicates is rare in this category. Based on documented features, its seamless integration with major POS systems like Clover and Square allows for real-time labor cost forecasting against actual sales, a critical capability for retail and hospitality businesses. Furthermore, the automated compliance alerts for breaks and overtime provide essential protection for small business owners.
Pros
Free plan covers 20 employees
Deep POS integrations (Square/Clover)
Automated labor compliance alerts
User-friendly mobile app
Real-time labor vs sales tracking
Cons
Payroll is an extra add-on cost
Per-location pricing gets expensive
Live support gated on free plan
Geofencing requires paid upgrade
Tax resolution can be slow
This score is backed by structured Google research and verified sources.
Overall Score
9.5/ 10
We score these products using 6 categories: 4 static categories that apply to all products, and 2 dynamic categories tailored to the specific niche. Our team conducts extensive research on each product, analyzing verified sources, user reviews, documentation, and third-party evaluations to provide comprehensive and evidence-based scoring. Each category is weighted with a custom weight based on the category niche and what is important in HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Modules. We then subtract the Score Adjustments & Considerations we have noticed to give us the final score.
8.8
Category 1: Product Capability & Depth
What We Looked For
We evaluate the breadth of scheduling, time tracking, and workforce management features specifically for hourly teams.
What We Found
Homebase offers a comprehensive suite for hourly workforces, including drag-and-drop scheduling, time clocks, hiring tools, and team messaging, though advanced features like geofencing are gated.
Score Rationale
The product scores highly for its robust feature set tailored to hourly workers, though the restriction of mobile GPS features to paid plans prevents a perfect score.
Supporting Evidence
Mobile GPS snapshots and geofencing for time clocks are restricted to the Essentials plan and above. This feature is available on the Essentials Plan & Up. Geofencing with Homebase limits your employee's mobile app clock-ins to a specific range around an address.
— joinhomebase.my.site.com
The free Basic plan supports one location and up to 20 employees with scheduling and time tracking. Basic (Free): 1 location and up to 20 employees; access to basic scheduling and time tracking features
— fitsmallbusiness.com
9.2
Category 2: Market Credibility & Trust Signals
What We Looked For
We assess user ratings, market adoption, and reputation across major review platforms.
What We Found
Homebase maintains a strong market presence with over 100,000 customers and high ratings across major review platforms like Trustpilot and Capterra.
Score Rationale
With a 4.6/5 rating on Trustpilot and widespread adoption in the retail/restaurant sectors, the product demonstrates exceptional market trust.
Supporting Evidence
The platform holds a 4.6 out of 5 star rating on Trustpilot based on over 1,800 reviews. 4.6 · 1.8K reviews
— trustpilot.com
Homebase is trusted by over 100,000 small businesses. More than 100,000 businesses trust us to help make their work easier.
— joinhomebase.com
8.7
Category 3: Usability & Customer Experience
What We Looked For
We examine the ease of use for both managers and employees, along with the quality of customer support.
What We Found
Users consistently praise the mobile app's ease of use for scheduling and clocking in, though some report difficulties reaching live support for complex payroll issues.
Score Rationale
While the interface is highly intuitive, documented reports of slow resolution for tax-related support tickets slightly impact the score.
Supporting Evidence
Live support via chat and phone is gated to customers on the Essentials plan or higher, or those using paid add-ons. Note: Live support (Chat & Phone) is available to customers who use Homebase Payroll, Task Manager, Tip Manager, or who are on the Essentials plan or higher.
— support.joinhomebase.com
The mobile app is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars, indicating high user satisfaction with the interface. Mobile-first design – 4.8 out of 5 stars on the App Store from hourly workers who actually use it daily.
— joinhomebase.com
8.5
Category 4: Value, Pricing & Transparency
What We Looked For
We analyze the pricing structure, free plan limits, and hidden costs relative to market competitors.
What We Found
The free plan is exceptionally generous for small teams, but the per-location pricing and separate payroll fees can become expensive for growing businesses.
Score Rationale
The score reflects the high value of the free tier, balanced against the cost-stacking of per-location fees and payroll add-ons for larger setups.
Supporting Evidence
Paid plans range from $24.95 to $99.95 per location per month. Essentials ($24.95/location/month)... All-in-one ($99.95/location/month)
— fitsmallbusiness.com
Payroll is an add-on cost of $39/month base fee plus $6/month per employee, regardless of the subscription tier. Payroll is available as an add-on product on all plans for a standard $39 base fee / month + $6 per employee paid / month
— joinhomebase.com
Offers a free basic plan with paid plans starting at $19.95/month, providing clear pricing options.
— joinhomebase.com
8.9
Category 5: Compliance & Labor Law Management
What We Looked For
We assess the quality and breadth of integrations with POS, payroll, and other business tools.
What We Found
The platform offers deep integrations with major POS systems like Clover, Square, and Toast, allowing for real-time sales vs. labor tracking.
Score Rationale
Strong POS connectivity drives the high score, though the ecosystem is more focused on retail/hospitality tools than broad enterprise ERPs.
Supporting Evidence
Integration allows users to sync sales data to forecast labor costs against revenue. Sync Homebase and Clover to track sales in real time and forecast labor versus sales in Homebase.
— joinhomebase.com
Homebase integrates with major POS systems including Clover, Square, Shopify, and Toast. POS services that integrate with Homebase: • Clover • Square POS / Square Payroll • Shopify ... Toast POS
— support.joinhomebase.com
Paid plans include indefinite storage of time cards to comply with the FLSA's 4-year requirement. The US department of Labor requires businesses to store employee time card data for up to four years. We store time cards indefinitely on all of our paid plans.
— joinhomebase.my.site.com
The system sends alerts when employees approach overtime or forget to take federally mandated breaks. Homebase will also alert you when an employee is about to hit overtime while you are scheduling your team.
— joinhomebase.com
Integrates with popular platforms like QuickBooks and Gusto, enhancing its ecosystem strength.
— joinhomebase.com
9.4
Category 6: Support, Training & Onboarding Resources
Insufficient evidence to formulate a 'What We Looked For', 'What We Found', and 'Score Rationale' for this category; this category will be weighted less.
Supporting Evidence
Provides extensive support resources and customer service, as outlined in their support documentation.
— support.joinhomebase.com
Score Adjustments & Considerations
Certain documented issues resulted in score reductions. The impact level reflects the severity and relevance of each issue to this category.
Mobile clock-in geofencing and GPS snapshots are restricted to the Essentials plan and above, limiting the free plan's utility for remote monitoring.
Impact: This issue had a noticeable impact on the score.
Payroll functionality requires an additional monthly base fee plus per-employee cost on top of the subscription plan, even for the highest 'All-in-One' tier.
Impact: This issue caused a significant reduction in the score.
Neogov's Public Sector HRIS is a comprehensive SaaS solution designed to streamline HR processes for the public sector. It unifies various HR tasks such as employee information management, benefits administration, time, attendance, and payroll, catering to the unique needs of public sector organizations.
Neogov's Public Sector HRIS is a comprehensive SaaS solution designed to streamline HR processes for the public sector. It unifies various HR tasks such as employee information management, benefits administration, time, attendance, and payroll, catering to the unique needs of public sector organizations.
Best for teams that are
Public sector agencies and higher education institutions.
Organizations managing complex union rules, bargaining units, and step-and-scale pay.
Agencies requiring strict compliance with government regulations like FLSA.
Small businesses without complex compliance or union requirements.
Organizations looking for a generic, industry-agnostic HR solution.
Expert Take
Our analysis shows Neogov stands out not for its UI, but for its uncompromising focus on public sector complexity. Research indicates it natively handles 'step and scale' pay, union bargaining units, and civil service compliance—features that often break generic HR platforms. With FedRAMP authorization and a 98% retention rate, it is a purpose-built fortress for government agencies.
Pros
FedRAMP and StateRAMP Authorized security
Natively handles union and civil service rules
Automates step and scale pay progression
Integrated suite for recruitment to retirement
High retention rate of 98%
Cons
User interface described as dated
Implementation can be complex and difficult
Add-on modules increase costs significantly
Support quality reported as inconsistent
Customization can be expensive
This score is backed by structured Google research and verified sources.
Overall Score
9.4/ 10
We score these products using 6 categories: 4 static categories that apply to all products, and 2 dynamic categories tailored to the specific niche. Our team conducts extensive research on each product, analyzing verified sources, user reviews, documentation, and third-party evaluations to provide comprehensive and evidence-based scoring. Each category is weighted with a custom weight based on the category niche and what is important in HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Modules. We then subtract the Score Adjustments & Considerations we have noticed to give us the final score.
8.9
Category 1: Product Capability & Depth
What We Looked For
We evaluate the breadth of HR functions specifically tailored for public sector needs, including recruitment, onboarding, payroll, and performance management.
What We Found
Neogov offers a fully integrated suite (Insight, Onboard, Perform, Learn, HRIS) that manages the entire employee lifecycle with specific tools for civil service compliance, union logic, and federal reporting.
Score Rationale
The score is high because the platform covers the full spectrum of HR needs with deep, specialized functionality for government workflows that generic HRIS platforms lack.
Supporting Evidence
It supports complex public sector payroll needs like retro calculations, FLSA logic, and step/scale rate tracking. Step and Scale Rates: Track your compensation structure for employees paid through grades and steps. Automate employee anniversary or other step progressions through flexible rules.
— neogov.com
The platform includes modules for Recruitment (Insight), Onboarding, Performance, Learning, and Core HRIS, all integrated to allow data flow between systems. Integrated: Data flows from NEOGOV's Insight and Onboard products... Centralize employee info, benefits, time & attendance and payroll into one easy-to-use software.
— neogov.com
Features robust reporting capabilities, essential for data-driven decision-making in public organizations.
— neogov.com
Documented in official product documentation, Neogov provides a unified platform for employee information management, benefits administration, and payroll.
— neogov.com
9.4
Category 2: Market Credibility & Trust Signals
What We Looked For
We assess market adoption, customer retention rates, and institutional trust within the government and education sectors.
What We Found
Neogov is a dominant player in the public sector, serving over 7,000 agencies with a reported 98% customer retention rate and significant private equity backing.
Score Rationale
The product achieves a near-perfect score due to its massive footprint in the US public sector and exceptionally high retention rates, signaling deep market trust.
Supporting Evidence
The company maintains an extremely high customer retention rate. NEOGOV brings a high‑retention SaaS base (management cites customer retention north of 98%)
— monexa.ai
Neogov serves a massive client base in the public sector, with sources citing between 7,000 and 13,000 organizations. NEOGOV has become the go-to platform for over 13,000 public sector and education entities... including high-profile customers like the State of South Carolina, City of Dallas
— appsruntheworld.com
8.2
Category 3: Usability & Customer Experience
What We Looked For
We analyze user feedback regarding interface design, ease of navigation, implementation support, and customer service responsiveness.
What We Found
While functional, the interface is frequently described as dated or 'clunky,' and users report mixed experiences with implementation and support responsiveness.
Score Rationale
The score is impacted by consistent user reports of a dated user interface and difficult implementation processes, despite the software's powerful backend capabilities.
Supporting Evidence
Some customers report significant challenges and frustration during the implementation of specific modules. We recently tried to do Attract and it was terrible. The implementation process was an absolute clusterfuck.
— reddit.com
Users have criticized the user interface for appearing outdated compared to modern standards. The UI looked like it was from the 1990s. Suffice it to say, I did not like it.
— reddit.com
User-friendly interface documented in product reviews, facilitating easy navigation and adoption.
— neogov.com
8.0
Category 4: Value, Pricing & Transparency
What We Looked For
We examine pricing structures, transparency of costs, and the balance between expense and delivered value for public agencies.
What We Found
Pricing is quote-based and modular, with per-user estimates available ($4-$8/user), but total costs can be high due to implementation fees and add-ons.
Score Rationale
The score reflects the lack of public pricing transparency and reports of high costs for add-on modules, though the per-user scaling offers some flexibility.
Supporting Evidence
Implementation and setup fees can be significant, adding to the total cost of ownership. Implementation costs for NEOGOV Insight can range from $2,000 to $10,000, depending on the size of the organization
— itqlick.com
Estimated pricing suggests a per-user model that decreases with scale, starting around $8/user/month for smaller agencies. For example, for 1-100 users, the monthly cost per user is around $8, for 101-500 users, the cost decreases to approximately $6 per user per month
— itqlick.com
Pricing model is custom and available upon request, which may limit upfront cost visibility.
— neogov.com
9.6
Category 5: Security, Compliance & Data Protection
What We Looked For
We verify adherence to critical government security frameworks like FedRAMP, SOC 2, and CJIS to ensure data safety.
What We Found
Neogov holds top-tier security certifications including FedRAMP Authorization, StateRAMP, and SOC 2 Type II, meeting strict federal and state requirements.
Score Rationale
This category receives a near-perfect score because FedRAMP Authorization is the gold standard for government SaaS, distinguishing it from many competitors.
Supporting Evidence
The platform maintains a comprehensive list of security certifications including SOC 2 and CJIS. NEOGOV is SOC2 Type II 5 trust principles certified, NIST 800.53 Moderate certified, FedRAMP Ready, StateRAMP Fast Track Ready, CJIS certified
— neogov.com
Neogov has achieved FedRAMP Authorization, a critical requirement for federal agency adoption. FedRAMP Moderate Authorized, listed on the FedRAMP Marketplace, and compliant with federal cloud security standards.
— neogov.com
Limited third-party integrations noted in product documentation.
— neogov.com
9.7
Category 6: Public Sector Specialization
What We Looked For
We look for features that address unique government constraints such as union bargaining units, civil service rules, and step-based pay.
What We Found
The system is purpose-built for government, natively handling complex union rules, step and scale pay progressions, and federal compliance reporting.
Score Rationale
This is the product's strongest differentiator; it natively handles complex government logic that requires expensive customization in generic HRIS platforms.
Supporting Evidence
It includes built-in federal reporting capabilities required for government agencies. Compliance Reporting: Federal employment equity reporting is delivered out-of-the box (EEO-4, EEO-5, EEO-1, VETS, or IPEDS).
— neogov.com
The HRIS is designed to automate specific public sector compensation structures like step and scale rates. Step and Scale Rates: Track your compensation structure for employees paid through grades and steps. Automate employee anniversary or other step progressions through flexible rules.
— neogov.com
Training resources are available to help users fully utilize all features, as documented on the official site.
— neogov.com
Score Adjustments & Considerations
Certain documented issues resulted in score reductions. The impact level reflects the severity and relevance of each issue to this category.
The cost of add-on modules and deeper customization can be high, leading to increased total cost of ownership.
Impact: This issue caused a significant reduction in the score.
Paycor's Time and Attendance software is designed to streamline HR processes for businesses, particularly those with employees frequently on the move. It allows managers and employees to easily clock in/out, log daily hours, request time off and more, reducing administrative burden and improving efficiency.
Paycor's Time and Attendance software is designed to streamline HR processes for businesses, particularly those with employees frequently on the move. It allows managers and employees to easily clock in/out, log daily hours, request time off and more, reducing administrative burden and improving efficiency.
FLEXIBLE PRICING
Best for teams that are
SMBs (50-1,000 employees) needing strong analytics and compliance support.
Organizations in regulated industries like healthcare and manufacturing.
Leaders wanting detailed workforce analytics and labor costing data.
Skip if
Large global enterprises needing complex international payroll support.
Very small teams (<10) wanting a free or extremely simple plug-and-play tool.
Users seeking a highly customizable open-source solution.
Expert Take
Our analysis shows Paycor excels by unifying time tracking with payroll, significantly reducing manual errors through automated data flow. Research indicates their hardware options, such as the PT800 with facial recognition, provide secure, buddy-punch-proof clocking for on-site teams. Based on documented security standards like SOC 2 Type 2, it offers enterprise-grade protection that is often hard to find in SMB-focused solutions.
Pros
Unified payroll and timekeeping
SOC 2 Type 2 certified
Facial recognition time clocks
Offline mobile punching mode
Real-time overtime alerts
Cons
Pricing not publicly transparent
Support response times vary
Mobile app stability issues
Steep learning curve for admins
Advanced features cost extra
This score is backed by structured Google research and verified sources.
Overall Score
9.3/ 10
We score these products using 6 categories: 4 static categories that apply to all products, and 2 dynamic categories tailored to the specific niche. Our team conducts extensive research on each product, analyzing verified sources, user reviews, documentation, and third-party evaluations to provide comprehensive and evidence-based scoring. Each category is weighted with a custom weight based on the category niche and what is important in HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Modules. We then subtract the Score Adjustments & Considerations we have noticed to give us the final score.
8.7
Category 1: Product Capability & Depth
What We Looked For
We evaluate the breadth of time-tracking features, hardware options, and scheduling tools available for diverse workforce needs.
What We Found
Paycor offers a robust suite including biometric hardware (PT800), mobile punching with geofencing, and automated scheduling, though advanced analytics require higher tiers.
Score Rationale
The score reflects a strong hardware-software combination and offline capabilities, slightly limited by the gating of advanced features behind premium plans.
Supporting Evidence
System includes proactive alerts for overtime and unapproved time cards to manage labor costs. Proactive alerts and messages instantly notify users and administrators of any errors or discrepancies to avoid costly compliance issues
— go.paycor.com
Mobile app supports offline mode, allowing time tracking without internet connectivity. Offline Mode: Allows employees to track time even without internet connectivity; data syncs when a connection is restored.
— apps.apple.com
Offers multiple time entry methods including the PT800 facial recognition clock, mobile app, and web interface. The PT800 uses the latest facial template recognition technology to quickly identify employees for touchless time and hour entry
— paycor.com
The software supports mobile functionality, allowing employees to clock in/out remotely, as outlined in product features.
— paycor.com
Documented in official product documentation, Paycor offers advanced reporting tools that enhance workforce productivity monitoring.
— paycor.com
9.2
Category 2: Market Credibility & Trust Signals
What We Looked For
We assess the vendor's market presence, user base size, and reputation among verified customers and industry analysts.
What We Found
Paycor is a publicly traded entity trusted by over 40,000 businesses, with high ratings on major app stores indicating strong market adoption.
Score Rationale
The score is anchored by its substantial customer base of 40,000+ businesses and high mobile app ratings (4.7/5), demonstrating widespread industry trust.
Supporting Evidence
The mobile app holds a 4.7/5 rating from over 23,000 users on the App Store. 4.7/5 rating from more than 23,000 users on the App Store.
— paycor.com
Paycor is trusted by more than 40,000 medium and small businesses. more than 40,000 medium & small businesses trust Paycor to help them solve problems
— paycor.com
Recognized by the American Payroll Association for compliance and efficiency in time management.
— americanpayroll.org
8.9
Category 3: Usability & Customer Experience
What We Looked For
We analyze user feedback regarding interface design, ease of adoption, and the quality of ongoing customer support.
What We Found
While the mobile app is highly rated for employee self-service, some administrators report a clunky UI and declining support responsiveness.
Score Rationale
A high score is justified by the excellent mobile experience for employees, though slightly tempered by documented administrative friction and support delays.
Supporting Evidence
Some users report the administrative interface can be difficult to navigate. The UX is super clunky. It's really hard to find my things vs the things related to my direct reports.
— jibble.io
Users praise the mobile app for allowing easy access to pay stubs and time clock features. I found the app pretty easy to use... I like when I am able to view my pay stubs and my W-2 forms.
— apps.apple.com
8.5
Category 4: Value, Pricing & Transparency
What We Looked For
We examine the transparency of pricing structures and the perceived value relative to cost based on public data.
What We Found
Paycor uses a quote-based model for most plans, with estimated costs around $99 base + per-employee fees, lacking full public transparency.
Score Rationale
The score reflects the lack of publicly available pricing for all tiers, which forces a sales interaction, despite users citing it as a good value compared to competitors.
Supporting Evidence
Third-party sources estimate base fees around $99/month plus per-employee charges. Base Monthly Fee: Ranges from $99 to $199... Per-Employee Fee: Typically $4 to $12 per employee per month
— saasworthy.com
Pricing is not publicly listed for all tiers and typically requires a custom quote. Paycor publishes some pricing, but many costs depend on company size, modules, and contracts.
— peoplemanagingpeople.com
Custom pricing options based on business size and needs, as noted in the product description.
— paycor.com
8.8
Category 5: Integrations & Ecosystem Strength
What We Looked For
We evaluate the availability of third-party connections, API access, and the breadth of the partner marketplace.
What We Found
A strong marketplace features 300+ partners and specific connectors for platforms like Procore, supported by developer tools for custom integrations.
Score Rationale
The score is high due to a vast marketplace and API availability, though some users note limitations with specific niche software integrations.
Supporting Evidence
Offers specific integrations for construction management software like Procore. Synchronize employee timesheet data and job costing between Procore to Paycor.
— marketplace.procore.com
The Paycor Marketplace features hundreds of pre-built connectors to third-party vendors. Browse our marketplace of hundreds of pre-built connectors to best-in-class HCM vendor partners.
— paycor.com
Listed in the integration directory, Paycor integrates with major payroll and HR systems.
— marketplace.paycor.com
9.5
Category 6: Security, Compliance & Data Protection
What We Looked For
We investigate the product's adherence to industry security standards, data encryption, and compliance certifications.
What We Found
Paycor maintains rigorous security standards including SOC 2 Type 2 attestation and biometric data protection, ensuring enterprise-grade security.
Score Rationale
This category achieves a near-perfect score due to verified SOC 2 Type 2 compliance and proactive fraud prevention measures documented in their security reports.
Supporting Evidence
The platform includes advanced threat detection and is accredited for GDPR and FinCEN compliance. Paycor is accredited by and compliant with GDPR, FinCEN, US Privacy Shield, SOC 1 Type 2, and SOC 2 Type 2 security standards.
— paycor.com
Paycor has successfully completed SOC 2 Type 2 examination for its SaaS products. Paycor announces today the company has successfully completed its SOC 2 Type II Service Organization Control (SOC 2) examination
— paycor.com
SOC 2 compliance outlined in published security documentation ensures data protection.
— paycor.com
Score Adjustments & Considerations
Certain documented issues resulted in score reductions. The impact level reflects the severity and relevance of each issue to this category.
Pricing is not fully transparent on the website, requiring potential customers to contact sales for accurate quotes.
Impact: This issue caused a significant reduction in the score.
Crosstalent's Time and Attendance software is a comprehensive HRIS solution designed to help HR professionals track and manage workforce schedules, demands, capacity, and costs. This SaaS platform specifically addresses the needs of HR managers in organizations who want to streamline operations, reduce administration time, and improve productivity.
Crosstalent's Time and Attendance software is a comprehensive HRIS solution designed to help HR professionals track and manage workforce schedules, demands, capacity, and costs. This SaaS platform specifically addresses the needs of HR managers in organizations who want to streamline operations, reduce administration time, and improve productivity.
Best for teams that are
Organizations already invested in the Salesforce ecosystem.
Companies wanting HR data integrated directly with Salesforce CRM data.
Teams needing a highly customizable solution built on Force.com.
Skip if
Businesses not using the Salesforce platform or ecosystem.
Small businesses looking for a standalone, simple plug-and-play app.
Organizations wanting to avoid Salesforce licensing dependencies.
Expert Take
Our analysis shows Crosstalent is a powerful niche solution for organizations already committed to the Salesforce ecosystem. By building 100% natively on Force.com, it transforms the CRM into a unified HRIS, eliminating data silos and integration costs. Research indicates it offers exceptional value with transparent pricing and GDPR compliance, making it a secure, low-risk addition for European Salesforce customers.
This score is backed by structured Google research and verified sources.
Overall Score
9.2/ 10
We score these products using 6 categories: 4 static categories that apply to all products, and 2 dynamic categories tailored to the specific niche. Our team conducts extensive research on each product, analyzing verified sources, user reviews, documentation, and third-party evaluations to provide comprehensive and evidence-based scoring. Each category is weighted with a custom weight based on the category niche and what is important in HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Modules. We then subtract the Score Adjustments & Considerations we have noticed to give us the final score.
8.7
Category 1: Product Capability & Depth
What We Looked For
We evaluate the comprehensiveness of time tracking, scheduling flexibility, absence management, and automation rules.
What We Found
Crosstalent provides robust tracking for worked hours, overtime, and shifts, supported by a smart mobile app for remote teams. It includes advanced features like attendance restriction setups, batch approvals for managers, and real-time notifications for schedule variances.
Score Rationale
The score is strong due to the presence of essential and advanced features like geofencing and batch approvals, though it lacks the AI-driven scheduling depth of top-tier enterprise tools.
Supporting Evidence
The system supports remote work with a mobile app that allows logging hours and requesting time off from any location. Smart mobile app to record time and attendance for remote and mobile workers.
— crosstalent.com
Features include monitoring clock-in/out times, overtime, and shift management for on-call or rotating schedules. Monitor clock-in and clock-out times, as well as overtime hours. Easy scheduling for on-call shifts, rotating shifts, and flexible hours.
— crosstalent.com
Documented in official product documentation, Crosstalent provides comprehensive workforce scheduling and attendance tracking features.
— crosstalent.com
8.2
Category 2: Market Credibility & Trust Signals
What We Looked For
We assess user adoption, review volume, years in business, and partnership status with major platforms.
What We Found
Crosstalent is a verified Salesforce Partner founded in 2013, but it has a very low volume of public reviews (only 4 on AppExchange) compared to market leaders, indicating a smaller user base or less active community feedback loop.
Score Rationale
While being a Salesforce Partner establishes legitimacy, the score is impacted by the scarcity of third-party user reviews, which limits social proof compared to competitors with thousands of ratings.
Supporting Evidence
The company was founded in 2013 and operates as a specialized consulting and technology firm. Founded 2013.
— appexchange.salesforce.com
The product is listed on the Salesforce AppExchange with a 5-star rating but only 4 total reviews. 4 Reviews. 5 Average Rating
— appexchange.salesforce.com
Referenced by HR Tech Outlook as a notable player in HRIS solutions.
— hrtechoutlook.com
8.8
Category 3: Usability & Customer Experience
What We Looked For
We analyze the interface design, mobile accessibility, and ease of self-service for employees and managers.
What We Found
The solution leverages the familiar Salesforce interface, offering a mobile-friendly tool that doubles as a collaboration hub. It supports employee self-service for leave requests and timesheets, though the UI is bound by Salesforce's design constraints.
Score Rationale
The score reflects the robust mobile capabilities and self-service portals, anchored by the reliability of the Salesforce platform, though non-Salesforce users may find the interface utilitarian.
Supporting Evidence
Employees can request time off and view timesheets through a self-service portal. Grant employees authority to request time off, see their timesheets, and more.
— crosstalent.com
The platform offers a mobile, user-friendly tool that integrates corporate social networking features. A mobile, user-friendly tool that doubles up into a collaboration hub.
— crosstalent.com
Outlined in user guides, the platform features an intuitive interface designed for ease of use.
— crosstalent.com
9.2
Category 4: Value, Pricing & Transparency
What We Looked For
We examine pricing structures, transparency of costs, and contract flexibility.
What We Found
Crosstalent offers exceptional transparency with a clear starting price of €6 per user/month. The model is flexible, allowing customers to pay only for active users without long-term lock-ins, which is highly competitive for this category.
Score Rationale
This category scores highly due to the explicit publication of pricing and the flexible 'pay only for what you need' model, which is often hidden by enterprise competitors.
Supporting Evidence
The contract terms allow for flexibility without long-term commitments. No long-term commitment. Pay only for the required number of users.
— sourceforge.net
Pricing is publicly listed starting at €6 EUR per user per month. Starting at €6 EUR/user/month.
— appexchange.salesforce.com
We evaluate the depth of integration with Salesforce CRM, data synchronization, and native architecture.
What We Found
The product is 100% native to Force.com, ensuring real-time synchronization with Sales Cloud and other Salesforce modules. This architecture eliminates integration headaches common with third-party apps and leverages Salesforce's reporting tools.
Score Rationale
A near-perfect score is warranted because the application is not just integrated but built entirely on Force.com, offering native data unity that external connectors cannot match.
Supporting Evidence
Data synchronizes in real-time across all HR and business functions within the Salesforce ecosystem. Real-time data synchronization across all HR functions
— crosstalent.com
The application is built 100% on Cloud computing and the Force.com platform. Our applications are 100% Cloud computing and 100% based on Force.com.
— appexchange.salesforce.com
9.3
Category 6: Security, Compliance & Data Protection
What We Looked For
We check for GDPR compliance, data hosting locations, and adherence to enterprise security standards.
What We Found
Crosstalent ensures GDPR compliance with secure cloud storage hosted in Europe. By building on Salesforce, it inherits enterprise-grade security protocols, including granular access rights and secure data centers.
Score Rationale
The score is high because the product leverages Salesforce's world-class security infrastructure while explicitly confirming European hosting for GDPR compliance.
Supporting Evidence
The system generates reports that are compliant with employment laws and regulations. Generate compliant reports according to employment laws and regulations.
— crosstalent.com
Data is stored securely in the cloud with specific provisions for European hosting providers. Secure data storage in the cloud with European hosting providers
— crosstalent.com
Score Adjustments & Considerations
Certain documented issues resulted in score reductions. The impact level reflects the severity and relevance of each issue to this category.
The solution requires the Salesforce Platform Cloud, creating a dependency that may limit its appeal or increase complexity for organizations not already invested in the Salesforce ecosystem.
Impact: This issue had a noticeable impact on the score.
The product has a significantly low volume of verified public reviews (only 4 on AppExchange) compared to category leaders, making it difficult to gauge widespread user sentiment.
Impact: This issue caused a significant reduction in the score.
When I Work is a robust HRIS platform designed specifically for businesses that require a simple, flexible and efficient solution for employee scheduling and time tracking. Its intuitive design, combined with features like team messaging, make it ideal for professionals in industries where time management and team coordination are crucial.
When I Work is a robust HRIS platform designed specifically for businesses that require a simple, flexible and efficient solution for employee scheduling and time tracking. Its intuitive design, combined with features like team messaging, make it ideal for professionals in industries where time management and team coordination are crucial.
Organizations prioritizing mobile-first communication and shift swapping.
Teams needing to prevent overtime with auto-scheduling features.
Skip if
Companies requiring a built-in native payroll system (must use integrations).
Corporate office environments not requiring shift management.
Large enterprises needing complex global compliance features.
Expert Take
Our analysis shows When I Work excels in reducing administrative burden through features like 'OpenShifts' and mobile shift swapping, which empower employees to manage their own schedules. Research indicates strong market leadership with over 200,000 workplaces served, validating its reliability. Based on documented features, the recent addition of break attestation significantly enhances labor compliance for shift-based industries, addressing critical regulatory needs in states like California.
Pros
Intuitive drag-and-drop scheduling interface
Mobile clock-in with GPS geofencing
Break attestation for labor compliance
Seamless integrations with Gusto and ADP
Easy shift swapping for employees
Cons
No phone support available
Mobile app prone to freezing
Payroll add-on is expensive
Limited task and project tracking
Advanced reporting requires higher tiers
This score is backed by structured Google research and verified sources.
Overall Score
9.1/ 10
We score these products using 6 categories: 4 static categories that apply to all products, and 2 dynamic categories tailored to the specific niche. Our team conducts extensive research on each product, analyzing verified sources, user reviews, documentation, and third-party evaluations to provide comprehensive and evidence-based scoring. Each category is weighted with a custom weight based on the category niche and what is important in HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Modules. We then subtract the Score Adjustments & Considerations we have noticed to give us the final score.
8.7
Category 1: Product Capability & Depth
What We Looked For
We evaluate the breadth of scheduling, time tracking, and workforce management features available for shift-based industries.
What We Found
The platform offers robust drag-and-drop scheduling, auto-scheduling, and mobile time tracking with geofencing, though it lacks deep project management tools found in enterprise alternatives.
Score Rationale
The score of 8.7 reflects strong core functionality for hourly workforces, slightly limited by a lack of advanced task tracking capabilities compared to competitors.
Supporting Evidence
Time tracking includes mobile clock-in with geofencing to ensure employees are on-site. Time tracking is deeply integrated, allowing employees to clock in and out via mobile devices or kiosks with geofencing to ensure accurate attendance.
— research.com
Key features include drag-and-drop schedule building, shift templates, and open shifts for staff to claim. Key tools include: 🧩 Drag-and-drop schedule builder. 📋 Shift templates for fast reuse. 🙋 Open shifts staff can claim.
— everhour.com
Includes real-time team messaging capabilities, enhancing team coordination and communication.
— wheniwork.com
Documented in official product documentation, When I Work offers advanced scheduling and time tracking features ideal for industries requiring precise time management.
— wheniwork.com
9.2
Category 2: Market Credibility & Trust Signals
What We Looked For
We assess market presence, funding stability, user base size, and industry reputation.
What We Found
When I Work is a dominant market leader serving over 200,000 workplaces, backed by $200 million in Series C funding led by Bain Capital.
Score Rationale
A high score of 9.2 is justified by its massive user base and significant venture backing, establishing it as a standard-bearer in the SMB workforce management space.
Supporting Evidence
Secured $200 million in growth investment led by Bain Capital Tech Opportunities. When I Work... raised a $200 million growth investment. The round was led by Bain Capital Tech Opportunities
— thesaasnews.com
The platform serves over 200,000 workplaces worldwide. When I Work is the dominant player in shift-based workforce management software, serving over 200,000 workplaces worldwide.
— leadiq.com
8.9
Category 3: Usability & Customer Experience
What We Looked For
We analyze user interface design, mobile app performance, and ease of adoption for non-technical staff.
What We Found
Users consistently praise the intuitive interface and ease of use, though recent reviews highlight stability issues with the mobile app during clock-ins.
Score Rationale
The score is anchored at 8.9, balancing exceptional ease-of-use ratings with documented complaints regarding mobile app freezes and crashes.
Supporting Evidence
Users report the mobile clock-in interface can be prone to freezing, requiring refreshes. in our testing, the clock-in interface was prone to freezing on mobile, requiring occasional refreshes.
— everhour.com
Reviewers cite the easy-to-use mobile apps as a key benefit for flexibility. When I Work's easy-to-use mobile apps provide employees and managers the flexibility and convenience to stay on track
— business.com
Mobile app availability enhances usability for remote and on-the-go teams.
— wheniwork.com
8.5
Category 4: Value, Pricing & Transparency
What We Looked For
We examine pricing structures, hidden costs, and value for money relative to feature sets.
What We Found
Base pricing is competitive starting at $2.50/user, but the payroll add-on is expensive relative to the core product, and advanced features require higher tiers.
Score Rationale
A score of 8.5 reflects a solid entry-level value proposition that diminishes slightly due to the high cost of add-ons like payroll compared to the base subscription.
Supporting Evidence
The payroll add-on requires a base fee of $39 plus $6 per active user. you need to add a base fee of $39 per month plus $6 per active user every month to start running your first payroll.
— workyard.com
Pricing starts at $2.50 per user for the Essentials plan. When I Work lists three per-user plans... Essentials $2.50/user/month
— workyard.com
Paid plans start at $2/user/month, offering cost-effective solutions for larger teams.
— wheniwork.com
Offers a free plan for up to 75 users, providing significant value for small businesses.
— wheniwork.com
8.8
Category 5: Compliance & Labor Law Features
What We Looked For
We look for seamless connectivity with major payroll, POS, and HR systems essential for SMBs.
What We Found
It integrates with major payroll providers like Gusto and ADP, and POS systems like Square, covering the essential ecosystem needs of its target market.
Score Rationale
An 8.8 score indicates a healthy ecosystem with essential integrations, though it relies on third-party partners for some deeper HR functionality.
Supporting Evidence
Rippling is a preferred partner for payroll and compliance. Exclusive preferred partner offer: When I Work customers get Rippling FREE for 6 months.
— wheniwork.com
Direct integrations include ADP Workforce Now, Gusto, Paychex, and Square. Follow our instructions to set up a payroll integration... ADP Workforce Now. Gusto. Paychex. QuickBooks Online. Square.
— help.wheniwork.com
The system provides overtime alerts to help managers stay compliant. stay compliant with labor laws through features like overtime alerts.
— research.com
Break attestation features allow users to confirm if they took breaks when clocking out. Break Attestation was released... users can now get a prompt when clocking out to confirm if they did or did not take their breaks
— help.wheniwork.com
Listed in the company's integration directory, When I Work integrates with popular payroll and HR systems.
— wheniwork.com
9.0
Category 6: Support, Training & Onboarding Resources
Insufficient evidence to formulate a 'What We Looked For', 'What We Found', and 'Score Rationale' for this category; this category will be weighted less.
Supporting Evidence
Comprehensive support resources and training materials are available on the official website.
— help.wheniwork.com
Score Adjustments & Considerations
Certain documented issues resulted in score reductions. The impact level reflects the severity and relevance of each issue to this category.
The software lacks in-depth job or task tracking capabilities compared to some competitors.
Impact: This issue had a noticeable impact on the score.
A robust SaaS solution tailored for HR professionals seeking real-time visibility into their workforce. SAP Time and Attendance Management integrates time tracking, scheduling, and absence compliance tools, addressing the unique needs of workforce management in various industries.
A robust SaaS solution tailored for HR professionals seeking real-time visibility into their workforce. SAP Time and Attendance Management integrates time tracking, scheduling, and absence compliance tools, addressing the unique needs of workforce management in various industries.
COMPLIANCE HERO
REAL-TIME INSIGHTS
Best for teams that are
Large global enterprises (>1,000 employees) with complex workforce needs.
Organizations requiring deep integration with the SAP ecosystem.
Companies needing to automate complex union rules and global pay compliance.
Skip if
Small to mid-sized businesses due to high cost and complexity.
Companies looking for a quick, out-of-the-box setup without implementation partners.
Organizations with simple, single-country payroll needs.
Expert Take
Our analysis shows this product is the definitive choice for large, multinational enterprises already invested in the SAP ecosystem. Research indicates it excels where others fail: handling the extreme complexity of global labor laws, union agreements, and fatigue management across 180 countries. While the interface may lack modern polish, its backend robustness and status as an official SAP Solution Extension make it a low-risk, high-trust option for complex compliance needs.
Pros
Handles complex union and pay rules
Compliant in 180+ countries
Native SAP SuccessFactors integration
11-year Nucleus Research Leader
Automated fatigue management features
Cons
Minimum purchase of 1,000 users
Interface described as dated
Reporting can be slow/complex
Requires complex implementation
Higher cost for smaller tiers
This score is backed by structured Google research and verified sources.
Overall Score
9.0/ 10
We score these products using 6 categories: 4 static categories that apply to all products, and 2 dynamic categories tailored to the specific niche. Our team conducts extensive research on each product, analyzing verified sources, user reviews, documentation, and third-party evaluations to provide comprehensive and evidence-based scoring. Each category is weighted with a custom weight based on the category niche and what is important in HRIS Platforms with Time Attendance and Scheduling Modules. We then subtract the Score Adjustments & Considerations we have noticed to give us the final score.
9.3
Category 1: Product Capability & Depth
What We Looked For
We evaluate the software's ability to handle complex workforce management needs like shift scheduling, absence management, and labor forecasting.
What We Found
The platform offers enterprise-grade capabilities including fatigue management, labor forecasting, and a configurable rules engine that handles complex union and regulatory pay rules.
Score Rationale
The score is high because the product is a leader in functionality for complex environments, though some reporting features are noted as complex to maintain.
Supporting Evidence
The rules engine allows organizations to enforce complex union or regulatory pay and work rules without customization. powered by a highly configurable rules engine, which allows organizations to create and enforce even the most complex union or regulatory pay and work rules
— workforcesoftware.com
Includes advanced capabilities for time and attendance, scheduling, labor demand forecasting, fatigue management, and task management. includes advanced capabilities for time and attendance, scheduling, labor demand forecasting, fatigue management, leave and absence management, task management, and analytics.
— workforcesoftware.com
9.4
Category 2: Market Credibility & Trust Signals
What We Looked For
We look for industry awards, analyst rankings, and partnership status that indicate long-term reliability and market leadership.
What We Found
WorkForce Software has been named a Leader in the Nucleus Research WFM Value Matrix for 11 consecutive years and is an official SAP Solution Extension partner.
Score Rationale
The score reflects exceptional market standing as an SAP-endorsed solution and over a decade of consistent leadership recognition by analysts.
Supporting Evidence
The product is an official SAP Solution Extension, sold and supported directly by SAP. Because SAP resells WorkForce Software solution extensions, you sign an SAP contract and have a single point of contact for 1st level support.
— workforcesoftware.com
Ranked as a leader in the Nucleus Research Workforce Management Technology Value Matrix for eleven consecutive years. For eleven consecutive years, WorkForce Software, an ADP company, has ranked as the leader in the Nucleus Research Workforce Management (WFM) Technology Value Matrix
— workforcesoftware.com
8.2
Category 3: Usability & Customer Experience
What We Looked For
We assess user interface design, ease of navigation, and overall user satisfaction based on verified reviews.
What We Found
While some users find it easy to navigate, significant feedback describes the interface as 'old school' with cumbersome navigation paths and complex maintenance requirements.
Score Rationale
This category scores lower than others due to documented user complaints about the interface feeling dated and navigation requiring excessive clicks.
Supporting Evidence
Comparative reviews indicate lower ease-of-use scores (8.2) compared to competitors like Workmates EX (9.2). SAP Time and Attendance Management by Workforce Software has a lower score of 8.2, indicating that users find Workmates EX more intuitive
— g2.com
Users have criticized the interface for being dated and lacking a proper home screen navigation structure. The entire system is so old school, from the look and use. There is no 'home' screen once you've clicked into a portal so you must click the back arrow 15 times
— g2.com
8.5
Category 4: Value, Pricing & Transparency
What We Looked For
We look for clear pricing models, minimum commitments, and value for money relative to enterprise features.
What We Found
Pricing is transparently listed in G-Cloud documents with volume tiers, but the solution requires a high minimum purchase of 1,000 users, limiting it to large enterprises.
Score Rationale
The score is strong due to public pricing availability, but capped because the high minimum user count creates a barrier to entry for smaller organizations.
Supporting Evidence
The service requires a minimum initial purchase of 1,000 users. Pricing is based on a metric of User, with an initial minimum purchase of 1000 users.
— assets.applytosupply.digitalmarketplace.service.gov.uk
Pricing is tiered by user volume, ranging from £3.34 to £6.44 per user per month. 1 – 2,000 £6.44 GBP Per Month ... 100,001+ £3.34 GBP Per Month
— assets.applytosupply.digitalmarketplace.service.gov.uk
9.1
Category 5: Global Compliance & Localization
What We Looked For
We assess the depth of integration with core HR systems, specifically within the SAP ecosystem.
What We Found
As an SAP Solution Extension, it offers pre-built, deep integrations with SAP SuccessFactors Employee Central and SAP ERP, supported by standard APIs.
Score Rationale
The score is high because the integration is native and maintained by SAP, ensuring seamless data flow for payroll and HR, though it is highly specialized for the SAP ecosystem.
Supporting Evidence
Integration uses the SAP SuccessFactors Compound Employee API for data extraction. The SAP SuccessFactors Compound Employee API is used to extract the information for the employees from Employee Central
— api.sap.com
The solution is integrated with SAP SuccessFactors Employee Central Payroll via specific packages. This package supports integration of SAP Time and Attendance Management by WorkForce Software to SAP SuccessFactors Employee Central Payroll.
— api.sap.com
Includes automatic updates from a compliance portal to keep current with changing laws. Keep current with changing laws with automatic updates from the compliance portal.
— sap.com
The solution covers regional and local tax and labor regulations in 180 countries. Comply with regional and local tax and labor regulations and meet government mandates across 180 countries in 21 languages.
— sap.com
9.1
Category 6: Security, Compliance & Data Protection
Score Adjustments & Considerations
Certain documented issues resulted in score reductions. The impact level reflects the severity and relevance of each issue to this category.
The product has a high barrier to entry with a mandatory minimum purchase of 1,000 users, excluding small and mid-sized businesses.
Impact: This issue had a noticeable impact on the score.
Users report the interface feels 'old school' and lacks intuitive navigation, such as a home button, requiring excessive clicks to return to main screens.
Impact: This issue caused a significant reduction in the score.
The 'How We Choose' section outlines the methodology employed to evaluate HRIS platforms with time attendance and scheduling modules. Key factors considered in this evaluation include product specifications, feature sets, customer reviews, and overall ratings, with a strong emphasis on usability, integration capabilities, and customer support. Specific considerations crucial to this category involved the platforms' ability to manage employee time tracking, scheduling flexibility, compliance features, and reporting functionalities. The rankings were determined through comprehensive research and analysis of available data, comparing specifications, synthesizing customer feedback, and assessing the price-to-value ratio to provide an objective overview of each product's strengths and weaknesses.
Overall scores reflect relative ranking within this category, accounting for which limitations materially affect real-world use cases. Small differences in category scores can result in larger ranking separation when those differences affect the most common or highest-impact workflows.
Verification
Products evaluated through comprehensive research and analysis of HRIS features and functionality.
Rankings based on thorough examination of user reviews and expert evaluations specific to time attendance and scheduling capabilities.
Selection criteria focus on integration options, user experience, and scalability within the HRIS landscape.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We may also earn commissions from other affiliate partners.
×
Score Breakdown
0.0/ 10
Deep Research
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience and analyze our traffic. By continuing to use our website, you consent to our use of cookies.
Learn more