We review products independently. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more


Looking beyond this page? Visit the main Building Materials guide.

Nails & Screws
Albert Richer

Nailing Down the Right Choice: What Customer Insights and Expert Analysis Reveal About Nails & Screws When it comes to nails and screws, not all options are created equal. Market research suggests that durability often hinges on materials—like stainless steel or galvanized coatings—which receive the highest ratings for rust resistance in various customer reviews. Interestingly, many consumers prioritize holding power, with brands like Grip-Rite frequently praised for their superior grip in expert comparisons. However, despite the hype, some features like decorative heads can be overrated; after all, how often do you sit and admire a screw? Data indicates that the length and gauge of fasteners are crucial for specific projects, with heavier-duty jobs demanding thicker screws. Many users report that the right choice can mean the difference between a sturdy build and a project gone awry. Nailing Down the Right Choice: What Customer Insights and Expert Analysis Reveal About Nails & Screws When it comes to nails and screws, not all options are created equal. Market research suggests that durability often hinges on materials—like stainless steel or galvanized coatings—which receive the highest ratings for rust resistance in various customer reviews.

1
Expert Score
6.0 / 10
568
86
RATED
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK
ALL-IN-ONE KIT
EASY INSTALL

Deck Plus Red Wood Screws

Deck Plus Red Wood Screws
13215 reviews
RATED
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK
ALL-IN-ONE KIT
EASY INSTALL

Pros

  • Rust-resistant
  • Durable epoxy coating
  • Coarse thread for secure installation
  • Torx/Star drive included
  • 73 pieces per box

Cons

  • Only available in red
  • May not be suitable for all wood types
  • Limited quantity per box

Expert Take

These screws are perfect for outdoor decking and fencing projects due to their rust-resistant capabilities and durable epoxy coating. The included Torx/Star drive also makes them easy to use, making them a popular choice among customers.

These 2-1/2 inch epoxy coated exterior wood and fence screws are perfect for outdoor use as they are rust-resistant. The coarse thread design makes them ideal for secure installations while the Torx/Star drive included ensures ease of use. Comes in a 1lb box containing 73 pieces.

Durable, rust-resistant exterior wood and fence screws with Torx/Star drive included.

2
Expert Score
6.0 / 10
289
20
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK
DIY ENTHUSIAST
PROFESSIONAL GRADE

400pcs Double-Sided Skirting Nails

400pcs Double-Sided Skirting Nails
79 reviews
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK
DIY ENTHUSIAST
PROFESSIONAL GRADE

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • Clean, professional finish
  • Versatile for various projects
  • High quantity
  • Included installation tools

Cons

  • Brand is unknown
  • May not suit all wood types
  • Limited information available

Expert Take

We love these skirting nails because they provide a seamless and professional finish to any woodwork. The double-sided design makes installation easy, and with 400 pieces included, there's plenty for multiple projects. The inclusion of 4 installation tools makes this set great value for money.

This set of 400 double-sided skirting nails includes 4 tools for seamless installation on solid wood trim. The nails are designed to be invisible once installed, providing a clean and professional finish. The product is suitable for use in various home improvement and construction projects.

Invisible double-sided skirting nails with 4 tools for easy and clean installation on solid wood trim.

3
Expert Score
6.0 / 10
436
89
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK

125 Pcs 5/16" x 3" Deck Screws Star Drive Construction Lag Screws 5lb Gold Ceramic Coated Bronze Rust Resistant for Outdoor Wood Fence Projects Stairs

125 Pcs 5/16" x 3" Deck Screws Star Drive Construction Lag Screws 5lb Gold Ceramic Coated Bronze Rust Resistant for Outdoor Wood Fence Projects Stairs
7 reviews
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: 125 Pcs 5/16" x 3" Deck Screws Star Drive Construction Lag Screws 5lb Gold Ceramic Coated Bronze Rust Resistant for Outdoor Wood Fence Projects Stairs

125 Pcs 5/16" x 3" Deck Screws Star Drive Construction Lag Screws 5lb Gold Ceramic Coated Bronze Rus

4
Expert Score
6.0 / 10
132
23
RATED
VARIETY PACK

376pcs Galvanized Nails Kit

376pcs Galvanized Nails Kit
9101 reviews
RATED
VARIETY PACK

Pros

  • Variety of sizes
  • Durable galvanized material
  • Comes with storage box
  • Great for multiple uses
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Brand is unknown
  • May not be suitable for heavy-duty tasks

Expert Take

Customers appreciate the variety of nail sizes available in this kit, making it versatile for various home improvement tasks. The galvanized material ensures durability, and the included storage box adds convenience. Despite the unknown brand, the high ratings and affordable price point make this product a popular choice among consumers.

This 376pcs Premium Hardware Nails Assortment Kit includes maximum length 2 inches galvanized nails in 6 different sizes. Ideal for picture hanging, woodworking, and wall mounting, these nails come neatly organized in a convenient storage box.

A comprehensive set of durable, galvanized nails in six sizes, perfect for a variety of home improvement tasks.

5
Expert Score
6.0 / 10
420
50
INVISIBLE FINISH

Double-Headed Skirting Nails 300-Pack

Double-Headed Skirting Nails 300-Pack
14 reviews
INVISIBLE FINISH

Pros

  • Invisible upon installation
  • Comes with necessary tool
  • Allows for seamless finish
  • High quantity pack
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Brand Unknown
  • May not be suitable for all types of wood

Expert Take

These nails are perfect for creating a professional, seamless finish on wood and MDF baseboards. They are easy to install and become invisible once in place, which means no unsightly nail heads on your baseboards. Plus, the pack comes with a 3 Sleeve Tool for easy installation.

This 300-pack of Double Headed Skirting Nails comes with a 3 Sleeve Tool, specifically designed for seamless Wood and MDF Baseboard Installation. The nails are invisible once installed, creating a clean, professional-looking finish on your baseboards.

Double-headed skirting nails for seamless baseboard installation.

6
Expert Score
6.0 / 10
358
81
BEST RELIABILITY
MOST LOVED CHOICE
BEST RELIABILITY
MOST LOVED CHOICE

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: OMOTOOL Brick Steel Nails Assortment Kit (350 pcs), Galvanized Concrete Wall Nail for Hanging Pictures and Woodworking, Cement Nails Suit for Drywall and Pine?5 Size Assortment (Black)

OMOTOOL Brick Steel Nails Assortment Kit (350 pcs), Galvanized Concrete Wall Nail for Hanging Pictur

7
Expert Score
6.0 / 10
382
88
VALUE
EPOXY COATED EXCELLENCE
LONG-LASTING DURABILITY
VALUE
EPOXY COATED EXCELLENCE
LONG-LASTING DURABILITY

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: Wood Screws 2 Inch, FIXLINK Deck Screws #8 x 2, 100 PCS, Epoxy Coated, T25 Star Bit Above 1500 Hour Salt Spray Coating Outdoor Decking Screws Excellent Rust Resistant for Wood Fence, Brown

Wood Screws 2 Inch, FIXLINK Deck Screws #8 x 2, 100 PCS, Epoxy Coated, T25 Star Bit Above 1500 Hour

8
Expert Score
6.0 / 10
440
20
BEST BUDGET PICK
BEST FOR THE MONEY
HIGH QUANTITY PACK

M-D Steel Concrete Nails

M-D Steel Concrete Nails
53 reviews
BEST BUDGET PICK
BEST FOR THE MONEY
HIGH QUANTITY PACK

Pros

  • Strong and durable
  • Ideal for concrete and masonry applications
  • High-quality steel

Cons

  • Size not suitable for all tasks
  • Can rust if exposed to moisture

Expert Take

We love these nails because of their high-quality steel construction which ensures durability and strength. They are ideal for various masonry and concrete applications, making them a versatile tool in building and renovation projects.

The M-D Building Products 19777 are 5/8 in. steel concrete nails used for fastening materials into concrete and masonry. They come in a 1 lb package and are made from high-quality steel, assuring durability and strength.

Durable and high-quality 5/8 in. steel concrete nails for masonry work.

9
Expert Score
6.2 / 10
261
15
HIDDEN PERFECTION
PERFECT FIT

600-Pc Hidden Deck Fasteners Set

600-Pc Hidden Deck Fasteners Set
4 reviews
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
TOP TRUSTED SCORE
HIDDEN PERFECTION
PERFECT FIT

Pros

  • Large quantity pack
  • Comes with installation tool
  • Hidden fastening for clean look
  • High-quality composite screws
  • Universal clips fit most decking

Cons

  • Brand unknown
  • May not fit all deck boards
  • Installation may be time-consuming

Expert Take

This product offers a clean, screw-free look for any deck by hiding the fasteners. The inclusion of an installation tool and high-quality composite screws makes this a comprehensive set for decking installation projects. Customers appreciate the universal clips that fit most decking boards, making this a versatile choice.

This set of 600 Hidden Deck Fasteners includes composite deck screws and universal decking clips. The product also comes with a star drive bit and a hidden fastener installation tool, making installation easy and hassle-free.

Complete set of 600 hidden deck fasteners with installation tool.

10
Expert Score
6.0 / 10
486
25
RUST-PROOF CHAMPION
HEAVY DUTY HERO

Deck Plus Epoxy Wood Screws

Deck Plus Epoxy Wood Screws
13215 reviews
RUST-PROOF CHAMPION
HEAVY DUTY HERO

Pros

  • Rust-resistant
  • Coarse thread for better grip
  • Included Torx/Star drive
  • Durable epoxy coating
  • Ideal for outdoor use

Cons

  • Red color may not suit all projects
  • Limited to wood and fence applications
  • Pack size could be larger

Expert Take

These screws are fantastic for outdoor projects, thanks to their rust-resistant epoxy coating. Customers appreciate the included Torx/Star drive and the reliable grip provided by the coarse thread design. Overall, they offer exceptional value and performance in wood and fence applications.

These are #10 x 4-inch red epoxy-coated exterior wood and fence screws, perfect for outdoor use. They come with a Torx/Star drive and feature a coarse thread design for improved grip in wood. The epoxy coating provides excellent rust resistance, making them ideal for decking and other outdoor applications.

Durable, rust-resistant screws for exterior wood and fence applications.

Product Comparison

Product Screw Length Rust Resistant Drive Type Includes installation tools Coating Type Ideal Use Rust-resistant Self-drilling feature Size Material type Quantity Material Pack Quantity Pack Size
1 Deck Plus Red Wood Screws
Yes
(Decking Screws)
Yes
(Decking Screws)
Torx/Star
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
Epoxy Coated
(Decking Screws)
Outdoor wood and fence applications
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
Yes
(Decking Screws)
2 400pcs Double-Sided Skirting Nails
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
Yes
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
No
(Wood Screws)
No
(Wood Screws)
Not specified
(Wood Screws)
Steel
(Wood Screws)
Yes
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
3 376pcs Galvanized Nails Kit
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
No
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
Yes
(Wood Screws)
No
(Wood Screws)
Up to 2 Inch
(Wood Screws)
Galvanized steel
(Wood Screws)
Yes
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
4 Double-Headed Skirting Nails 300-Pack
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
Yes
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
No
(Wood Screws)
No
(Wood Screws)
Not specified
(Wood Screws)
Steel
(Wood Screws)
Yes
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
N/A
(Wood Screws)
5 M-D Steel Concrete Nails
Yes
(Decking Screws)
No
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
None
(Decking Screws)
Concrete and masonry
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
Yes
(Decking Screws)
6 600-Pc Hidden Deck Fasteners Set
N/A
(Decking Screws)
Yes
(Decking Screws)
Star drive
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
Composite
(Decking Screws)
Hidden fastening for decks
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
Yes
(Decking Screws)
7 Deck Plus Epoxy Wood Screws
Yes
(Decking Screws)
Yes
(Decking Screws)
Torx/Star
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
Epoxy Coated
(Decking Screws)
Outdoor wood and fence applications
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
N/A
(Decking Screws)
Yes
(Decking Screws)
1

Deck Plus Red Wood Screws

Screw Length (Decking Screws)
Yes
Rust Resistant (Decking Screws)
Yes
Drive Type (Decking Screws)
Torx/Star
Includes installation tools (Decking Screws)
N/A
Coating Type (Decking Screws)
Epoxy Coated
Ideal Use (Decking Screws)
Outdoor wood and fence applications
Rust-resistant (Decking Screws)
N/A
Self-drilling feature (Decking Screws)
N/A
Size (Decking Screws)
N/A
Material type (Decking Screws)
N/A
Quantity (Decking Screws)
N/A
Material (Decking Screws)
N/A
Pack Quantity (Decking Screws)
N/A
Pack Size (Decking Screws)
Yes
2

400pcs Double-Sided Skirting Nails

Screw Length (Wood Screws)
N/A
Rust Resistant (Wood Screws)
N/A
Drive Type (Wood Screws)
N/A
Includes installation tools (Wood Screws)
Yes
Coating Type (Wood Screws)
N/A
Ideal Use (Wood Screws)
N/A
Rust-resistant (Wood Screws)
No
Self-drilling feature (Wood Screws)
No
Size (Wood Screws)
Not specified
Material type (Wood Screws)
Steel
Quantity (Wood Screws)
Yes
Material (Wood Screws)
N/A
Pack Quantity (Wood Screws)
N/A
Pack Size (Wood Screws)
N/A
3

376pcs Galvanized Nails Kit

Screw Length (Wood Screws)
N/A
Rust Resistant (Wood Screws)
N/A
Drive Type (Wood Screws)
N/A
Includes installation tools (Wood Screws)
No
Coating Type (Wood Screws)
N/A
Ideal Use (Wood Screws)
N/A
Rust-resistant (Wood Screws)
Yes
Self-drilling feature (Wood Screws)
No
Size (Wood Screws)
Up to 2 Inch
Material type (Wood Screws)
Galvanized steel
Quantity (Wood Screws)
Yes
Material (Wood Screws)
N/A
Pack Quantity (Wood Screws)
N/A
Pack Size (Wood Screws)
N/A
4

Double-Headed Skirting Nails 300-Pack

Screw Length (Wood Screws)
N/A
Rust Resistant (Wood Screws)
N/A
Drive Type (Wood Screws)
N/A
Includes installation tools (Wood Screws)
Yes
Coating Type (Wood Screws)
N/A
Ideal Use (Wood Screws)
N/A
Rust-resistant (Wood Screws)
No
Self-drilling feature (Wood Screws)
No
Size (Wood Screws)
Not specified
Material type (Wood Screws)
Steel
Quantity (Wood Screws)
Yes
Material (Wood Screws)
N/A
Pack Quantity (Wood Screws)
N/A
Pack Size (Wood Screws)
N/A
5

M-D Steel Concrete Nails

Screw Length (Decking Screws)
Yes
Rust Resistant (Decking Screws)
No
Drive Type (Decking Screws)
N/A
Includes installation tools (Decking Screws)
N/A
Coating Type (Decking Screws)
None
Ideal Use (Decking Screws)
Concrete and masonry
Rust-resistant (Decking Screws)
N/A
Self-drilling feature (Decking Screws)
N/A
Size (Decking Screws)
N/A
Material type (Decking Screws)
N/A
Quantity (Decking Screws)
N/A
Material (Decking Screws)
N/A
Pack Quantity (Decking Screws)
N/A
Pack Size (Decking Screws)
Yes
6

600-Pc Hidden Deck Fasteners Set

Screw Length (Decking Screws)
N/A
Rust Resistant (Decking Screws)
Yes
Drive Type (Decking Screws)
Star drive
Includes installation tools (Decking Screws)
N/A
Coating Type (Decking Screws)
Composite
Ideal Use (Decking Screws)
Hidden fastening for decks
Rust-resistant (Decking Screws)
N/A
Self-drilling feature (Decking Screws)
N/A
Size (Decking Screws)
N/A
Material type (Decking Screws)
N/A
Quantity (Decking Screws)
N/A
Material (Decking Screws)
N/A
Pack Quantity (Decking Screws)
N/A
Pack Size (Decking Screws)
Yes
7

Deck Plus Epoxy Wood Screws

Screw Length (Decking Screws)
Yes
Rust Resistant (Decking Screws)
Yes
Drive Type (Decking Screws)
Torx/Star
Includes installation tools (Decking Screws)
N/A
Coating Type (Decking Screws)
Epoxy Coated
Ideal Use (Decking Screws)
Outdoor wood and fence applications
Rust-resistant (Decking Screws)
N/A
Self-drilling feature (Decking Screws)
N/A
Size (Decking Screws)
N/A
Material type (Decking Screws)
N/A
Quantity (Decking Screws)
N/A
Material (Decking Screws)
N/A
Pack Quantity (Decking Screws)
N/A
Pack Size (Decking Screws)
Yes

How We Rank Products

How We Evaluate at This Level

This category highlights the strongest overall performers across closely related, specialized use cases.

Rather than evaluating products in isolation, we first analyze performance within highly specific niches, such as Anchor Screws, Concrete Screws, Decking Screws and Drywall Screws .

From those niche evaluations, we surface products that consistently demonstrate strength across multiple use cases.

Only solutions that perform at a high level across several specialized categories are featured here. This approach allows us to identify well-rounded platforms that excel beyond a single narrow scenario and represent the best all-around options within this broader category.

Our Evaluation Process

The 'How We Choose' section for nails and screws products highlights a comprehensive research methodology focused on key evaluation factors such as specifications, features, customer reviews, and ratings. Important considerations in this category include the material composition, corrosion resistance, size options, and compatibility with various applications, which significantly influence performance and user satisfaction. Rankings are determined by analyzing data from multiple customer feedback platforms, reviewing product ratings, and comparing specifications to assess overall value. This objective approach ensures that the curated selection reflects the most reliable and sought-after options available in the market.

Overall scores reflect relative ranking within this category, accounting for which limitations materially affect real-world use cases. Small differences in category scores can result in larger ranking separation when those differences affect the most common or highest-impact workflows.

Verification

  • Products evaluated through comprehensive research and analysis of specifications and user feedback.
  • Rankings based on a thorough comparison of customer reviews and expert insights in the nails and screws category.
  • Selection criteria focus on durability, material quality, and user satisfaction ratings for nails and screws.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We may also earn commissions from other affiliate partners.

Frequently Asked Questions About Nails & Screws

What makes a nails & screws the "best"?

We evaluate products based on quality, performance, value for money, user reviews, durability, and ease of use. Our rankings are updated regularly to reflect the latest market offerings and user feedback.

How often do you update your nails & screws recommendations?

Our team continuously monitors the market for new products and updates our recommendations quarterly. We also adjust rankings based on user feedback and new testing results.

What if I'm looking for a specific type of nails & screws?

Our top 10 list covers the most popular and highly-rated options. If you have specific requirements, check our detailed product descriptions and pros/cons to find the best match for your needs.

×

Score Breakdown

0.0 / 10

What This Award Means