We review products independently. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more


To explore all connected software, head to our Saddles & Tack category.

Trail Riding Saddles
Albert Richer

Finding the Right Fit: A Deep Dive into the Best Trail Riding Saddles When it comes to trail riding saddles, the market is flooded with options, but what do the reviews really say? Research suggests that features like weight distribution and comfort are paramount for riders tackling long distances. In fact, many consumers report that lightweight materials like synthetic nylon are consistently praised for reducing fatigue over hours in the saddle. Meanwhile, brands such as Circle Y are noted for their custom-fit options, which expert analysis indicates can significantly enhance riding comfort. Interestingly, while some might think extra padding is a must, data indicates that too much can actually lead to discomfort. Many riders prefer a saddle that balances comfort and stability without excessive bulk. Finding the Right Fit: A Deep Dive into the Best Trail Riding Saddles When it comes to trail riding saddles, the market is flooded with options, but what do the reviews really say? Research suggests that features like weight distribution and comfort are paramount for riders tackling long distances.

Similar Categories
1
Expert Score
9.8 / 10
307
50
VALUE

Southwestern Equine Dusty's Saddle Pouch, Cell Phone Holder for Saddle Sack Insulated Liner [Waterproof Version]

Southwestern Equine Dusty's Saddle Pouch, Cell Phone Holder for Saddle Sack Insulated Liner [Waterproof Version]
468 reviews
VALUE

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: Southwestern Equine Dusty's Saddle Pouch, Cell Phone Holder for Saddle Sack Insulated Liner [Waterproof Version]

Southwestern Equine Dusty's Saddle Pouch, Cell Phone Holder for Saddle Sack Insulated Liner [Waterpr

2
Expert Score
9.7 / 10
360
34
TRAIL ESSENTIALS
POPULAR PICKS
TRAIL ESSENTIALS
POPULAR PICKS

Harrison Howard Trail Seat Saver Western Tack Saddle Ride-on Pad with Cushion Bottom Helps Distribute Back Pressure

Harrison Howard Trail Seat Saver Western Tack Saddle Ride-on Pad with Cushion Bottom Helps Distribute Back Pressure
135 reviews
$34.99 Amazon
TRAIL ESSENTIALS
POPULAR PICKS
TRAIL ESSENTIALS
POPULAR PICKS

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: Harrison Howard Trail Seat Saver Western Tack Saddle Ride-on Pad with Cushion Bottom Helps Distribute Back Pressure

Harrison Howard Trail Seat Saver Western Tack Saddle Ride-on Pad with Cushion Bottom Helps Distribut

3
Expert Score
9.5 / 10
226
39

Tahoe Premium Heavy Duty Nylon Waterproof Western Saddle Cover With Six Elastic Holding Straps and Stirrup Covers - Fits Most Saddle Sizes and Types - Multiple Colors Available

Tahoe Premium Heavy Duty Nylon Waterproof Western Saddle Cover With Six Elastic Holding Straps and Stirrup Covers - Fits Most Saddle Sizes and Types - Multiple Colors Available
411 reviews

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: Tahoe Premium Heavy Duty Nylon Waterproof Western Saddle Cover With Six Elastic Holding Straps and Stirrup Covers - Fits Most Saddle Sizes and Types - Multiple Colors Available

Tahoe Premium Heavy Duty Nylon Waterproof Western Saddle Cover With Six Elastic Holding Straps and S

4
Expert Score
9.4 / 10
420
16
BEST RELIABILITY
MOST LOVED CHOICE

Tough 1 Saddle Carrier Deluxe Western 600 Denier Nylon 61-1026

Tough 1 Saddle Carrier Deluxe Western 600 Denier Nylon 61-1026
11 reviews
BEST RELIABILITY
MOST LOVED CHOICE

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: Tough 1 Saddle Carrier Deluxe Western 600 Denier Nylon 61-1026

Tough 1 Saddle Carrier Deluxe Western 600 Denier Nylon 61-1026

5
Expert Score
9.2 / 10
319
38
VALUE PICKS

Tough 1 Heavy Denier Nylon Saddle Cover in Prints

Tough 1 Heavy Denier Nylon Saddle Cover in Prints
1300 reviews
$23.92 Amazon
VALUE PICKS

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: Tough 1 Heavy Denier Nylon Saddle Cover in Prints

Tough 1 Heavy Denier Nylon Saddle Cover in Prints

6
Expert Score
9.1 / 10
138
17
RATED
ECO-FRIENDLY
STYLISH RIDES

Harrison Howard Premium Waterproof/Breathable Fleece-Lined Ride-on English Saddle Cover with Slot for Girth-Blue

Harrison Howard Premium Waterproof/Breathable Fleece-Lined Ride-on English Saddle Cover with Slot for Girth-Blue
898 reviews
RATED
ECO-FRIENDLY
STYLISH RIDES

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: Harrison Howard Premium Waterproof/Breathable Fleece-Lined Ride-on English Saddle Cover with Slot for Girth-Blue

Harrison Howard Premium Waterproof/Breathable Fleece-Lined Ride-on English Saddle Cover with Slot fo

7
Expert Score
8.9 / 10
542
76
BEST

TrailMax 500 Series Saddle Bag - Insulated, Padded Drink Holder for Horses; Compatible with Western & Endurance Saddles; Blue Piping, No Bottle Included

TrailMax 500 Series Saddle Bag - Insulated, Padded Drink Holder for Horses; Compatible with Western & Endurance Saddles; Blue Piping, No Bottle Included
12 reviews
BEST

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: TrailMax 500 Series Saddle Bag - Insulated, Padded Drink Holder for Horses; Compatible with Western & Endurance Saddles; Blue Piping, No Bottle Included

TrailMax 500 Series Saddle Bag - Insulated, Padded Drink Holder for Horses; Compatible with Western

8
Expert Score
8.8 / 10
388
28
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK
WATERPROOF WONDERS
STORAGE SAVVY
WATERPROOF WONDERS
STORAGE SAVVY

2 Pcs Horse Saddle Bag for Horses Gear Carrier Pommel Packet Waterproof Saddle Sack Pannier with Pocket for Water Bottle Camera Cell Phone Key, Black, Brown

2 Pcs Horse Saddle Bag for Horses Gear Carrier Pommel Packet Waterproof Saddle Sack Pannier with Pocket for Water Bottle Camera Cell Phone Key, Black, Brown
19 reviews
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK
WATERPROOF WONDERS
STORAGE SAVVY
WATERPROOF WONDERS
STORAGE SAVVY

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: 2 Pcs Horse Saddle Bag for Horses Gear Carrier Pommel Packet Waterproof Saddle Sack Pannier with Pocket for Water Bottle Camera Cell Phone Key, Black, Brown

2 Pcs Horse Saddle Bag for Horses Gear Carrier Pommel Packet Waterproof Saddle Sack Pannier with Poc

9
Expert Score
8.6 / 10
307
91
EASY TO FIND EVERYWHERE
BEST AVAILABILITY

Tough 1 600 Denier Western Saddle Cover

Tough 1 600 Denier Western Saddle Cover
80 reviews
EASY TO FIND EVERYWHERE
BEST AVAILABILITY
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: Tough 1 600 Denier Western Saddle Cover

Tough 1 600 Denier Western Saddle Cover

10
Expert Score
8.5 / 10
361
69
BEST BUDGET PICK
BEST FOR THE MONEY
VALUE PICKS

Tough 1 Western Saddle Carrier

Tough 1 Western Saddle Carrier
35 reviews
$36.00 StatelineTack
BEST BUDGET PICK
BEST FOR THE MONEY
VALUE PICKS

Pros

  • High quality
  • Reliable
  • Good value

Cons

  • Check reviews
  • Limited info

Expert Take

Popular choice with good ratings

Amazon product: Tough 1 Western Saddle Carrier

Tough 1 Western Saddle Carrier

Product Comparison

Product Price Brand Customer Rating Pros Cons Review Count
1 Southwestern Equine Dusty's Saddle Pouch, Cell Phone Holder for Saddle Sack Insulated Liner [Waterproof Version]
$17.95 N/A 4.60 stars (468 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
2 Harrison Howard Trail Seat Saver Western Tack Saddle Ride-on Pad with Cushion Bottom Helps Distribute Back Pressure
$34.99 s?k=horse+saddle+pad 4.30 stars (135 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
3 Tahoe Premium Heavy Duty Nylon Waterproof Western Saddle Cover With Six Elastic Holding Straps and Stirrup Covers - Fits Most Saddle Sizes and Types - Multiple Colors Available
$21.99 N/A 4.50 stars (411 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
4 Tough 1 Saddle Carrier Deluxe Western 600 Denier Nylon 61-1026
$95.98 N/A 4.40 stars (11 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
5 Tough 1 Heavy Denier Nylon Saddle Cover in Prints
$23.92 N/A 4.60 stars (1300 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
6 Harrison Howard Premium Waterproof/Breathable Fleece-Lined Ride-on English Saddle Cover with Slot for Girth-Blue
$32.99 N/A 4.80 stars (898 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
7 TrailMax 500 Series Saddle Bag - Insulated, Padded Drink Holder for Horses; Compatible with Western & Endurance Saddles; Blue Piping, No Bottle Included
$31.95 N/A 3.80 stars (12 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
8 2 Pcs Horse Saddle Bag for Horses Gear Carrier Pommel Packet Waterproof Saddle Sack Pannier with Pocket for Water Bottle Camera Cell Phone Key, Black, Brown
$38.99 N/A 4.20 stars (19 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
9 Tough 1 600 Denier Western Saddle Cover
$20.95 N/A 4.20 stars (80 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
10 Tough 1 Western Saddle Carrier
$46.64 N/A 4.00 stars (35 reviews) High quality, Reliable, Good value Check reviews, Limited info Yes
1

Southwestern Equine Dusty's Saddle Pouch, Cell Phone Holder for Saddle Sack Insulated Liner [Waterproof Version]

Price
$17.95
Brand
N/A
Customer Rating
4.60 stars (468 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes
2

Harrison Howard Trail Seat Saver Western Tack Saddle Ride-on Pad with Cushion Bottom Helps Distribute Back Pressure

Price
$34.99
Brand
s?k=horse+saddle+pad
Customer Rating
4.30 stars (135 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes
3

Tahoe Premium Heavy Duty Nylon Waterproof Western Saddle Cover With Six Elastic Holding Straps and Stirrup Covers - Fits Most Saddle Sizes and Types - Multiple Colors Available

Price
$21.99
Brand
N/A
Customer Rating
4.50 stars (411 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes
4

Tough 1 Saddle Carrier Deluxe Western 600 Denier Nylon 61-1026

Price
$95.98
Brand
N/A
Customer Rating
4.40 stars (11 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes
5

Tough 1 Heavy Denier Nylon Saddle Cover in Prints

Price
$23.92
Brand
N/A
Customer Rating
4.60 stars (1300 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes
6

Harrison Howard Premium Waterproof/Breathable Fleece-Lined Ride-on English Saddle Cover with Slot for Girth-Blue

Price
$32.99
Brand
N/A
Customer Rating
4.80 stars (898 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes
7

TrailMax 500 Series Saddle Bag - Insulated, Padded Drink Holder for Horses; Compatible with Western & Endurance Saddles; Blue Piping, No Bottle Included

Price
$31.95
Brand
N/A
Customer Rating
3.80 stars (12 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes
8

2 Pcs Horse Saddle Bag for Horses Gear Carrier Pommel Packet Waterproof Saddle Sack Pannier with Pocket for Water Bottle Camera Cell Phone Key, Black, Brown

Price
$38.99
Brand
N/A
Customer Rating
4.20 stars (19 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes
9

Tough 1 600 Denier Western Saddle Cover

Price
$20.95
Brand
N/A
Customer Rating
4.20 stars (80 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes
10

Tough 1 Western Saddle Carrier

Price
$46.64
Brand
N/A
Customer Rating
4.00 stars (35 reviews)
Pros
High quality, Reliable, Good value
Cons
Check reviews, Limited info
Review Count
Yes

Similar Categories

How We Rank Products

Our Evaluation Process

The 'How We Choose' section for trail riding saddles outlines a rigorous methodology focused on key factors such as product specifications, features, customer reviews, and overall ratings. Essential considerations in this category include comfort, durability, weather resistance, and compatibility with various saddle types, as these elements significantly impact the rider's experience and satisfaction. Rankings were determined by analyzing comparative data from multiple sources, including product specifications, customer feedback, and overall price-to-value ratios, ensuring a comprehensive assessment of each saddle's performance and suitability for trail riding. This research methodology emphasizes an evidence-based approach to facilitate informed decision-making for customers seeking the best trail riding saddles.

Overall scores reflect relative ranking within this category, accounting for which limitations materially affect real-world use cases. Small differences in category scores can result in larger ranking separation when those differences affect the most common or highest-impact workflows.

Verification

  • Products evaluated through comprehensive research and analysis of user feedback and expert recommendations.
  • Selection criteria focus on saddle fit, comfort features, and material quality specific to trail riding.
  • Comparison methodology analyzes customer ratings and reviews to ensure informed recommendations for riders.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We may also earn commissions from other affiliate partners.

Frequently Asked Questions About Trail Riding Saddles

What makes a trail riding saddles the "best"?

We evaluate products based on quality, performance, value for money, user reviews, durability, and ease of use. Our rankings are updated regularly to reflect the latest market offerings and user feedback.

How often do you update your trail riding saddles recommendations?

Our team continuously monitors the market for new products and updates our recommendations quarterly. We also adjust rankings based on user feedback and new testing results.

What if I'm looking for a specific type of trail riding saddles?

Our top 10 list covers the most popular and highly-rated options. If you have specific requirements, check our detailed product descriptions and pros/cons to find the best match for your needs.

×

Score Breakdown

0.0 / 10

What This Award Means