We review products independently. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more


This page offers a narrow focus — the wider Printer Paper overview is here.

Cardstock Printer Paper
Albert Richer

Unpacking Cardstock Printer Paper: What Customer Insights and Expert Analysis Reveal About Quality and Performance When it comes to cardstock printer paper, not all options are created equal. Market research suggests that customers often prioritize weight and thickness, with papers in the 80lb to 110lb range consistently receiving the highest praise for their sturdiness. Reviews indicate that brands like Neenah and Hammermill frequently rank well, thanks to their impressive color reproduction and reliability for various printing needs. Interestingly, many users report that smooth finishes are essential for achieving vibrant images, while textured options may be better suited for crafting projects. But what’s truly overrated? Some consumers tend to overlook the importance of acid-free materials; research shows that these can prevent yellowing over time, which is particularly important for archival projects. Unpacking Cardstock Printer Paper: What Customer Insights and Expert Analysis Reveal About Quality and Performance When it comes to cardstock printer paper, not all options are created equal. Market research suggests that customers often prioritize weight and thickness, with papers in the 80lb to 110lb range consistently receiving the highest praise for their sturdiness.

Similar Categories
1
Expert Score
9.8 / 10
502
39
VALUE
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK

Heavy White Cardstock

Heavy White Cardstock
2043 reviews
VALUE
EXPERT TRUSTED
TOP EDITORIAL PICK

Pros

  • Heavy-duty quality
  • Printer-compatible
  • Ideal for crafting
  • Great for DIY invitations
  • High customer rating

Cons

  • Brand unknown
  • Only 30 sheets per pack

Expert Take

Customers love this product for its high quality and versatility. The heavy weight gives a professional feel to DIY projects, and its compatibility with home printers makes it convenient for a variety of uses. Despite the brand being unknown, it has a high customer rating showing trust and satisfaction.

This 8.5 x 11, 230gsm heavy cardstock is perfect for a range of DIY activities including scrapbooking, crafting, and creating custom invitations. The 85lb weight ensures a sturdy and premium feel, and it's compatible with most printers for convenient at-home use.

Premium heavy cardstock for crafting and printing needs.

2
Expert Score
9.7 / 10
316
30
RATED
LIGHTWEIGHT OPTION

Neenah White Index Cardstock

Neenah White Index Cardstock
14972 reviews
RATED
LIGHTWEIGHT OPTION

Pros

  • High quality
  • Bright white color
  • Lightweight but durable
  • Perfect for printing and crafting

Cons

  • Only one color
  • May be too thin for some uses

Expert Take

This cardstock is a crowd favorite because of its high quality and versatility. Whether for printing professional documents or for crafting projects, it delivers an excellent performance every time. Its bright white color and lightweight properties make it easy to handle and ideal for a variety of uses.

This is a pack of 300 sheets of Neenah Index Cardstock, measuring 8.5' x 11'. The cardstock is lightweight with a 90 lb/163 gsm weight and has a brightness rating of 94. Ideal for professional and personal use, it offers superior quality for printing and crafting needs.

Quality, bright white, lightweight cardstock, perfect for printing and crafting.

3
Expert Score
9.5 / 10
506
98
ECO-FRIENDLY CHOICE
VERSATILE USE

PrintWorks Vellum Bristol Cardstock

PrintWorks Vellum Bristol Cardstock
3918 reviews
ECO-FRIENDLY CHOICE
VERSATILE USE

Pros

  • High-quality
  • Bright white for vibrant prints
  • Versatile for craft and office use
  • Sustainable Forestry Initiative Certified
  • Made in USA

Cons

  • Only 100 sheets per pack
  • Not suitable for very heavy-duty projects

Expert Take

We love the PrintWorks Vellum Bristol Cardstock because of its superior quality and versatility. It's perfect for printing, crafting, and office tasks, and its brightness rating ensures vibrant results. Plus, it's sustainable and made in the USA, making it an eco-friendly choice.

The PrintWorks Vellum Bristol Cardstock is a high-quality, 67 lb/147 gsm paper ideal for school, craft, and office use. This US-made product is SFI Certified, with a brightness rating of 92, providing crisp and vibrant prints. The package includes 100 sheets of 8.5' x 11' cardstock.

Premium, bright white cardstock for versatile use.

4
Expert Score
9.4 / 10
296
24

PrintWorks Premium White Cardstock

PrintWorks Premium White Cardstock
2429 reviews

Pros

  • High print quality
  • Ideal for various uses
  • Great brightness level
  • Certified sustainable
  • Made in USA

Cons

  • Only available in white
  • May be too thick for some printers

Expert Take

Customers love the PrintWorks White Cardstock for its versatility and high print quality. Its 92 brightness level ensures vibrantly printed materials, making it ideal for crafts, school projects, and office use. Plus, it's SFI certified, which means it's a sustainable choice for eco-conscious consumers.

The PrintWorks White Cardstock is an 8.5 x 11 inches, 67 lb/147 gsm paper, perfect for crafting, school, and office use. It is SFI certified, made in the USA, and has a brightness of 92, ensuring excellent print quality. The pack contains 250 sheets of vellum Bristol cardstock.

High-quality, bright, versatile cardstock for crafting and printing needs.

5
Expert Score
9.2 / 10
499
55
BEST
HEAVY-DUTY USE
HIGH BRIGHTNESS

Neenah Mediumweight White Index Paper

Neenah Mediumweight White Index Paper
14742 reviews
BEST
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
TOP TRUSTED SCORE
HEAVY-DUTY USE
HIGH BRIGHTNESS

Pros

  • High paper quality
  • Mediumweight for durability
  • Bright white for clear prints
  • Generous quantity in pack
  • Suitable for multiple uses

Cons

  • Price may be high for some
  • Free delivery only on orders above $35
  • Brand not specified

Expert Take

The Neenah White Index Paper is loved for its superior quality and versatility. Its mediumweight makes it durable enough for various projects, while its bright white color ensures clear, sharp prints. With 300 sheets per pack, it offers excellent value for money.

The Neenah Mediumweight White Index Paper is a pack of 300, 8.5 x 11 inches sheets with a 199 gsm weight and 94 brightness. It's ideal for both professional and creative uses, providing a high-quality surface for printing, writing, and crafting.

Premium quality, mediumweight, bright white index paper suitable for various purposes.

6
Expert Score
9.1 / 10
196
79
BUDGET-FRIENDLY

Springhill White Cardstock Paper

Springhill White Cardstock Paper
2900 reviews
BUDGET-FRIENDLY

Pros

  • Versatile use
  • Printer-compatible
  • High-quality finish
  • Lightweight yet durable
  • Good value for money

Cons

  • May not be suitable for heavy-duty printing
  • Color may vary slightly

Expert Take

We love the Springhill White Cardstock Paper because it offers versatility in printing various projects, from greeting cards to flyers. Its lightweight yet durable nature ensures a high-quality finish for all printing needs. Plus, it offers excellent value for money with a pack of 250 sheets.

The Springhill White Cardstock Paper is a pack of 250 sheets of 8.5" x 11" 90lb, 163gsm cardstock. This premium lightweight cardstock has a smooth finish, making it ideal for printing greeting cards, flyers, and scrapbooking projects. It's compatible with most printers and offers a high-quality finish for all your printing needs.

Premium, lightweight white cardstock paper for versatile printing needs.

7
Expert Score
8.9 / 10
372
20
CRAFTING DELIGHT
USA MADE

Thick White Cardstock 8.5x11

Thick White Cardstock 8.5x11
50 reviews
CRAFTING DELIGHT
USA MADE

Pros

  • Thick and durable
  • Bright white color
  • Versatile usage
  • Great for crafts and professional needs
  • Value for money

Cons

  • Brand unknown
  • May be too thick for some printers

Expert Take

This cardstock is loved for its thickness and durability, making it perfect for crafting or professional needs. The bright white color adds a clean, professional look to any project. Despite its high quality, it is reasonably priced, providing excellent value for money.

This heavy-duty cardstock is perfect for a variety of projects, from DIY cards and invitations to business cards and crafts. Measuring 8.5 x 11 inches, each sheet has a weight of 75 lb/200 gsm, ensuring durability and a high-quality feel. The pack includes 40 sheets of bright white cardstock, providing ample material for your creative or professional needs.

Durable, 75 lb white cardstock for professional and creative use.

8
Expert Score
8.8 / 10
435
32
BEST BUDGET PICK
BEST FOR THE MONEY
EASY TO FIND EVERYWHERE
CREATIVE PROJECTS
VIBRANT COLORS

Astrobrights Black Cardstock 100-Pack

Astrobrights Black Cardstock 100-Pack
5900 reviews
BEST BUDGET PICK
BEST FOR THE MONEY
EASY TO FIND EVERYWHERE
CREATIVE PROJECTS
VIBRANT COLORS

Pros

  • High quality material
  • Vibrant black color
  • Ideal size for projects
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Great for crafts and presentations

Cons

  • May be too thick for some printers
  • Color might not suit all projects

Expert Take

This Astrobrights cardstock stands out for its high-quality, durable material and vibrant black color. Customers love it for the creative freedom it provides for their projects, from crafting to making professional presentations.

Astrobrights Eclipse Black Cardstock is a high-quality, 65 lb cover weight paper. The 8.5 x 11 size is perfect for a range of projects, and the vibrant black color ensures a standout look.

Durable, brilliantly black cardstock ideal for creative projects.

9
Expert Score
8.6 / 10
534
53
BEST RELIABILITY
MOST LOVED CHOICE
SMOOTH TEXTURE

White Cardstock 8.5x11 65Lb

White Cardstock 8.5x11 65Lb
82 reviews
BEST RELIABILITY
MOST LOVED CHOICE
SMOOTH TEXTURE

Pros

  • High quality material
  • Versatile usage
  • Ideal size for printing
  • Sturdy and premium feel
  • Excellent value for money

Cons

  • Brand is not specified
  • Might be too thick for some printers

Expert Take

We love this product because of its versatility and quality. Suitable for a wide range of printing needs, from invitations to gift tags, it's a great addition to any home or office. Plus, the high-quality 65lb cardstock ensures a sturdy, professional finish that customers appreciate.

This pack of white cardstock from an unknown brand consists of 40 sheets of 180gsm paper, perfect for a variety of printing needs. With a size of 8.5x11, it's ideal for printing invitations, gift tags, Christmas cards, and more. The cardstock is of 65lb cover card stock paper quality, giving it a sturdy and premium feel.

Premium 65lb white cardstock for versatile printing needs.

10
Expert Score
8.5 / 10
153
66
PROFESSIONAL FINISH

Thick Off-White Cardstock

Thick Off-White Cardstock
50 reviews
PROFESSIONAL FINISH

Pros

  • High quality
  • Heavy-duty 200 gsm weight
  • Versatile uses
  • Free delivery on orders over $35
  • High customer rating

Cons

  • Brand unknown
  • Only one color availability

Expert Take

We love this product for its high-quality, thick paper weight that's perfect for all kinds of projects. Customers appreciate its versatility and the fact that it's heavy-duty enough for both professional and personal use. The high customer rating speaks to its reliable performance.

This heavy-duty 75 lb/200 gsm Cardstock comes in a pack of 40 sheets, each measuring 8.5 x 11 inches. It's cream-colored and perfect for a variety of uses such as invitations, business cards, DIY craft projects, menus, drawing, and more. The product offers free delivery on orders over $35 and enjoys a high rating of 4.8/5.

Heavy-duty, cream-colored cardstock for versatile use.

Product Comparison

Product Product Type Sheet Count Weight (gsm) Brightness Sustainability Certification Price
1 Heavy White Cardstock
Heavy Cardstock Yes Yes No None $6.00
2 Neenah White Index Cardstock
Index Cardstock Yes Yes Yes None $13.00
3 PrintWorks Vellum Bristol Cardstock
Vellum Bristol Yes Yes Yes SFI Certified $7.00
4 PrintWorks Premium White Cardstock
White Cardstock Yes Yes Yes SFI Certified $15.00
5 Neenah Mediumweight White Index Paper
Index Paper Yes Yes Yes None $17.00
6 Springhill White Cardstock Paper
White Cardstock Yes Yes No None $10.34
7 Thick White Cardstock 8.5x11
Thick Cardstock Yes Yes No None $6.00
8 Astrobrights Black Cardstock 100-Pack
Black Cardstock Yes Yes No None $12.85
9 White Cardstock 8.5x11 65Lb
White Cardstock Yes Yes No None $5.00
10 Thick Off-White Cardstock
Off-White Cardstock Yes Yes No None $6.00
1

Heavy White Cardstock

Product Type
Heavy Cardstock
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
No
Sustainability Certification
None
Price
$6.00
2

Neenah White Index Cardstock

Product Type
Index Cardstock
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
Yes
Sustainability Certification
None
Price
$13.00
3

PrintWorks Vellum Bristol Cardstock

Product Type
Vellum Bristol
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
Yes
Sustainability Certification
SFI Certified
Price
$7.00
4

PrintWorks Premium White Cardstock

Product Type
White Cardstock
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
Yes
Sustainability Certification
SFI Certified
Price
$15.00
5

Neenah Mediumweight White Index Paper

Product Type
Index Paper
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
Yes
Sustainability Certification
None
Price
$17.00
6

Springhill White Cardstock Paper

Product Type
White Cardstock
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
No
Sustainability Certification
None
Price
$10.34
7

Thick White Cardstock 8.5x11

Product Type
Thick Cardstock
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
No
Sustainability Certification
None
Price
$6.00
8

Astrobrights Black Cardstock 100-Pack

Product Type
Black Cardstock
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
No
Sustainability Certification
None
Price
$12.85
9

White Cardstock 8.5x11 65Lb

Product Type
White Cardstock
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
No
Sustainability Certification
None
Price
$5.00
10

Thick Off-White Cardstock

Product Type
Off-White Cardstock
Sheet Count
Yes
Weight (gsm)
Yes
Brightness
No
Sustainability Certification
None
Price
$6.00

Similar Categories

How We Rank Products

Our Evaluation Process

The 'How We Choose' section for cardstock printer paper products emphasizes a rigorous research methodology focused on key factors such as specifications, features, customer reviews, and ratings. Important considerations in this category include paper weight, thickness, texture, and compatibility with various printers, which all significantly influence print quality and user satisfaction. The evaluation process involved a comprehensive analysis of available data, comparing specifications across multiple products, analyzing customer feedback and ratings to gauge performance and value, and assessing the price-to-value ratio to identify the most suitable options for diverse printing needs. This objective approach ensures that the rankings reflect informed choices based on thorough research and comparative analysis.

Overall scores reflect relative ranking within this category, accounting for which limitations materially affect real-world use cases. Small differences in category scores can result in larger ranking separation when those differences affect the most common or highest-impact workflows.

Verification

  • Products evaluated through comprehensive research and analysis of user feedback and expert insights.
  • Rankings based on detailed analysis of specifications, customer ratings, and industry trends.
  • Selection criteria focus on key factors such as print quality, paper weight, and compatibility with various printers.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We may also earn commissions from other affiliate partners.

Frequently Asked Questions About Cardstock Printer Paper

What makes a cardstock printer paper the "best"?

We evaluate products based on quality, performance, value for money, user reviews, durability, and ease of use. Our rankings are updated regularly to reflect the latest market offerings and user feedback.

How often do you update your cardstock printer paper recommendations?

Our team continuously monitors the market for new products and updates our recommendations quarterly. We also adjust rankings based on user feedback and new testing results.

What if I'm looking for a specific type of cardstock printer paper?

Our top 10 list covers the most popular and highly-rated options. If you have specific requirements, check our detailed product descriptions and pros/cons to find the best match for your needs.

×

Score Breakdown

0.0 / 10

What This Award Means