Search Categories

What Are The Best Organic Cheeses in 2025

Your Ultimate Guide to Discovering the Best Organic Cheeses: Flavor, Quality, and Sustainability Unveiled When it comes to choosing the best organic cheeses, understanding what sets them apart is crucial. First and foremost, consider the sourcing of the milk—look for cheeses made from grass-fed cows or pasture-raised goats, as this often enhances flavor and nutritional value. Next, examine the production methods; artisanal cheeses crafted by small-scale producers typically offer a depth of taste and character that mass-produced options can lack. Don't overlook the importance of certifications—ensuring your cheese is USDA organic guarantees that it meets strict guidelines for animal welfare and environmental sustainability. In addition to these factors, pay attention to flavor profiles and textures that align with your personal preferences. Whether you enjoy creamy bries or sharp cheddars, there's an organic option to satisfy your palate. Also, consider pairing suggestions to elevate your cheese experience, as certain wines and fruits can complement the unique characteristics of organic cheeses beautifully. By keeping these key elements in mind, you can confidently select the best organic cheeses that not only taste great but also support sustainable farming practices. Dive into the world of organic dairy products with this guide and savor every bite!

1

Organic Valley, Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Organic Valley, Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese
Buy Now $31.08

Why We Love It

Reviewers love Organic Valley's Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese for its rich, intense flavor and smooth texture. They appreciate that it's made from organic, non-GMO ingredients, and many have noted that it melts beautifully, making it perfect for cooking. The fact that it's produced by a cooperative of family farms also resonates with many customers.

Pros

  • Organic
  • Non-GMO
  • Full-flavored

Cons

  • Can be a bit crumbly
  • Pricey compared to non-organic options

Block of organic sharp cheddar cheese from Organic Valley.

Organic Valley's Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese is a flavorful, full-bodied cheese made from organic milk sourced from family farms. Aged to perfection, this sharp cheddar offers an intense flavor with a creamy texture. The product is USDA certified organic, non-GMO, and free from artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives. Enjoy it on its own, or use it to add depth to your favorite recipes.

2

Organic Valley, Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Buy Now $35.00

Why We Love It

Customers love the rich, full flavor of this cheddar cheese, with many noting that it's the best they've ever tasted. Reviewers appreciate that it's made from organic milk, and that the company values sustainable farming practices. The sharpness of the cheese is frequently praised, adding an extra kick to meals and snacks.

Pros

  • Organic
  • No antibiotics, synthetic hormones, or toxic pesticides
  • Great flavor

Cons

  • Higher cost compared to non-organic cheese
  • Some users find the taste too sharp

A 7oz block of sharp cheddar cheese made from organic milk

Organic Valley's Sharp Cheddar Cheese is made from the milk of pasture-raised cows, without the use of antibiotics, synthetic hormones, or toxic pesticides. It is naturally aged for a minimum of eight months to develop a full, robust flavor. This cheese is perfect for sandwiches, cooking, or as a snack on its own.

Product Comparison

Compare features across all products in this category

6 Features 5 Products Updated Oct 04, 2025
Product USDA Certified Organic Flavor Profile Texture Primary Use Nutritional Benefits Form
1 Organic Valley, Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese
Yes Sharp and intense Creamy, slightly crumbly Cooking and snacking High in protein and calcium Block
2 365 Everyday Value, Organic Feta Cheese
Yes Tangy Crumbly Salads and pasta Lower fat option Crumbled
3 Organic Valley, Organic Mozzarella Cheese
Yes Mild Smooth and creamy Pizza and cooking Excellent source of calcium and protein Block
4 365 Everyday Value, Organic Monterey Jack Cheese
Yes Mild and buttery Smooth Sandwiches and melting Healthier alternative to processed cheese Block
5 Organic Valley, Organic Parmesan Cheese
Yes Rich and nutty Grated Sprinkling on dishes High in protein and calcium Grated
1

Organic Valley, Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese

USDA Certified Organic
Yes
Flavor Profile
Sharp and intense
Texture
Creamy, slightly crumbly
Primary Use
Cooking and snacking
Nutritional Benefits
High in protein and calcium
Form
Block
2

365 Everyday Value, Organic Feta Cheese

USDA Certified Organic
Yes
Flavor Profile
Tangy
Texture
Crumbly
Primary Use
Salads and pasta
Nutritional Benefits
Lower fat option
Form
Crumbled
3

Organic Valley, Organic Mozzarella Cheese

USDA Certified Organic
Yes
Flavor Profile
Mild
Texture
Smooth and creamy
Primary Use
Pizza and cooking
Nutritional Benefits
Excellent source of calcium and protein
Form
Block
4

365 Everyday Value, Organic Monterey Jack Cheese

USDA Certified Organic
Yes
Flavor Profile
Mild and buttery
Texture
Smooth
Primary Use
Sandwiches and melting
Nutritional Benefits
Healthier alternative to processed cheese
Form
Block
5

Organic Valley, Organic Parmesan Cheese

USDA Certified Organic
Yes
Flavor Profile
Rich and nutty
Texture
Grated
Primary Use
Sprinkling on dishes
Nutritional Benefits
High in protein and calcium
Form
Grated

Frequently Asked Questions About Organic Cheeses

What makes a organic cheeses the "best"?

We evaluate products based on quality, performance, value for money, user reviews, durability, and ease of use. Our rankings are updated regularly to reflect the latest market offerings and user feedback.

How often do you update your organic cheeses recommendations?

Our team continuously monitors the market for new products and updates our recommendations quarterly. We also adjust rankings based on user feedback and new testing results.

Do you test all the products you recommend?

Yes, whenever possible, we physically test products in our labs. For products we can't test directly, we rely on verified user reviews, expert opinions, and detailed specifications to make informed recommendations.

What if I'm looking for a specific type of organic cheeses?

Our top 10 list covers the most popular and highly-rated options. If you have specific requirements, check our detailed product descriptions and pros/cons to find the best match for your needs.